Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardIntegrating Evidence from Auditory Sources

A student is writing an argumentative essay for the AP Spanish Language exam. The prompt asks: "Should university education be completely free for all students?"

The student's thesis is: "While the rising cost of tuition places a heavy burden on students, making university completely free for everyone is not the ideal solution; instead, a progressive tuition system based on family income would better balance accessibility and educational quality."

The student is listening to the auditory source, which is an interview with an educational economist. The economist states: "If we eliminate tuition entirely for everyone, universities will lose a vital income source, which could lead to overcrowded classrooms and a decline in academic quality. Financial aid should be directed exclusively to those who truly need it."

Which of the following sentences best integrates the evidence from this auditory source to effectively support the student's thesis?

  1. Although some argue for universally free education, the economist in the interview warns that this policy could lead to overcrowded classrooms, reinforcing the argument that a progressive payment system is necessary to maintain academic standards.Answer
  2. B
    The auditory source is an interview with an economist who explains that eliminating tuition completely causes universities to lose money, which lowers academic quality and overcrowds classrooms.
  3. C
    As demonstrated by the article's discussion of student loans and the graph showing rising costs, the financial burden is too high, proving that a progressive system is the only way to save higher education.
  4. D
    Making university free will cause institutions to lose a vital source of income and lead to a decline in academic quality, which means that we need a progressive system instead.

Answer

The sentence that explicitly attributes the warning about overcrowded classrooms to the economist in the interview and connects it directly to the student's argument for a progressive payment system.
The correct answer successfully synthesizes the auditory evidence because it does two critical things: it clearly attributes the information to the specific source (the economist in the interview), and it actively applies the economist's warning to support the student's unique thesis about needing a progressive payment system. It moves beyond mere summary into active argumentation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the student's thesis statement.
The thesis argues for a progressive tuition system to balance accessibility with educational quality, rejecting universally free tuition.
Effective synthesis requires evidence to serve the specific argument being made.
2
Identify the core message of the auditory source.
The economist argues that universally free tuition will remove vital funding, lowering academic quality, and suggests targeting aid only to those in need.
You must understand the source's stance to use it accurately.
3
Evaluate how well each option integrates the audio with the thesis.
One option merely summarizes, one fails to cite the source, one ignores the audio completely, and one successfully blends the audio's warning with the thesis's proposed solution.
Synthesis requires both proper attribution (citation) and argumentation (connecting the source to the thesis).
4
Select the sentence that demonstrates true synthesis.
The correct answer explicitly mentions the economist from the interview and uses their point about overcrowded classrooms to justify the student's progressive payment model.
This is the only option that moves beyond summary to actively use the auditory evidence in service of the essay's specific claim.

Key Concept

Integrating Evidence from Auditory Sources

Hints

1
Remember that 'synthesis' means combining the source's ideas with your own argument, not just repeating what the source said.
2
Look for an option that explicitly mentions where the information came from AND connects it to the idea of a 'progressive payment system'.

Practice More

Review how to properly introduce quotes and paraphrased information using attribution tags (e.g., 'Según la fuente auditiva...').
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Integrating Evidence from Auditory Sources

More questions from this topic