Question

Difficulty: MediumCorroborating Claims Across Sources

Two sources address the traditional volcanic dry-farming viticulture (*enarenado*) practiced in La Geria, Lanzarote (Canary Islands):

Source 1 (Audio Broadcast Excerpt)
*From an interview on the agricultural program 'Voces del Campo' with agronomist Mateo Delgado:*
"When volcanic eruptions blanketed fertile valleys with porous volcanic gravel (*picón*) in the 18th century, local viticulturists adapted by digging conical depressions into the soil. This layer of lapilli serves as a natural moisture trap: it absorbs nocturnal humidity from ocean breezes and prevents soil water evaporation caused by intense solar radiation and Atlantic winds. Nevertheless, because each depression contains only an individual vine surrounded by a semicircular stone wall, field management and grape harvesting must be performed entirely by hand rather than standard machinery."

Source 2 (Agronomic Research Summary)
*From a published study on arid-zone agricultural heritage:*
"The *enarenado* system of Lanzarote relies on a 20–30 cm stratum of basaltic tephra to sustain viticulture in a desert-like biome with under 150 mm of annual rainfall. Microclimatic analyses indicate that the mulch's porous structure drastically minimizes subsurface evaporation while capturing ambient dew. While this geological adaptation allows high-quality viticulture without external irrigation, the geometric layout of individual funnel-shaped pits (*hoyos*) and protective windbreak walls (*abrigos*) completely precludes the introduction of tractor-based harvesting machinery, keeping labor requirements elevated."

Which of the following conclusions is directly corroborated by both sources?

  1. The volcanic gravel layer facilitates essential moisture retention in an arid climate, though the resulting structural layout mandates manual field labor.Answer
  2. B
    The primary threat to the longevity of the vineyards is the total depletion of underlying soil nutrients caused by historical volcanic activity.
  3. C
    The basaltic tephra layer reduces soil water evaporation rates by a measured 70% compared to adjacent unmulched agricultural parcels.
  4. D
    Recent modernization efforts have enabled automated harvesting machines to navigate the steep conical depressions without damaging stone walls.

Answer

The volcanic gravel layer facilitates essential moisture retention in an arid climate, though the resulting structural layout mandates manual field labor.
The correct response synthesizes the two primary findings shared by both sources: (1) the hygroscopic volcanic gravel/lapilli layer conserves and captures vital moisture, allowing viticulture in an arid climate without artificial irrigation, and (2) the physical architecture of individual pits and stone windbreaks prevents the deployment of harvesting machinery, making manual labor mandatory.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Source 1 for core claims regarding agricultural function and operational constraints.
Source 1 establishes that volcanic gravel (*picón*) absorbs humidity and restricts moisture evaporation, but individual pits and walls require all harvesting to be done manually rather than with machinery.
Identifying the central technical mechanism and operational requirement in the first source provides baseline criteria for corroboration.
2
Analyze Source 2 to determine overlapping claims supported by independent evidence.
Source 2 confirms that basaltic tephra minimizes evaporation and captures dew in an arid climate, while the pit geometry and windbreak walls rule out mechanized harvesters and keep manual labor demands high.
Corroboration requires identifying shared factual findings that appear across both independent media.
3
Evaluate the answer choices to identify the statement supported by both texts while rejecting single-source details or contradictions.
The claim regarding moisture retention enabling farming while physical terrain necessitates manual labor is directly affirmed in both accounts.
Cross-source synthesis demands selecting the shared conclusion that is mutually verifiable in both records.

Key Concept

Cross-source corroboration involves synthesizing print and audio texts to identify shared factual claims, mutual perspectives, or corroborated conclusions while filtering out isolated details or contradictory assertions.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question