Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Main Ideas and Supporting Details

Read the following excerpt from a journalistic article on environmental resource management:

In coastal communities across central Chile, the management of benthic fisheries has undergone a structural transformation through the implementation of territorial user rights for artisanal fishing guilds. Historically, centralized top-down harvesting bans struggled to prevent the depletion of key gastropod species, such as the prized *Concholepas concholepas* (loco). In contrast, the current co-management framework grants local artisanal syndicates exclusive extraction rights over designated marine parcels in exchange for rigorous adherence to scientifically determined annual quotas. Participating fishing cooperatives collaborate directly with regional marine biologists to perform periodic underwater population censuses and enforce community-based surveillance against poaching. Recent long-term ecological assessments reveal that these co-managed reserves maintain significantly higher benthic biomass, greater species richness, and more stable reproductive densities than adjacent open-access waters. Rather than treating local fishers solely as regulatory targets, this model positions artisanal organizations as primary ecological custodians, demonstrating that sustainable resource management succeeds when scientific governance aligns directly with localized economic stewardship.

Which of the following statements best expresses the main idea of the article?

  1. A
    Underwater population censuses conducted by marine biologists represent the primary mechanism for preventing species depletion along the coast.
  2. B
    Top-down commercial extraction bans have proven to be the most effective long-term strategy for maintaining marine biodiversity in artisanal regions.
  3. Empowering local artisanal fishing guilds to co-manage designated marine zones alongside scientists creates more resilient and sustainable ecosystems than centralized bans.Answer
  4. D
    Co-management initiatives will shortly lead to the total prohibition of artisanal fishing practices throughout South American waters.

Answer

Empowering local artisanal fishing guilds to co-manage designated marine zones alongside scientists creates more resilient and sustainable ecosystems than centralized bans.
The correct response accurately synthesizes the central claim of the article: that replacing ineffective centralized top-down bans with a collaborative co-management framework between artisanal cooperatives and scientists results in superior ecological resilience and resource sustainability.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage structure and identify the core problem-solution dynamic
The text contrasts historically ineffective centralized bans with a successful co-management framework established between artisanal fishing syndicates and marine biologists.
Understanding the contextual contrast helps separate supporting historical context from the central thesis.
2
Examine the concluding synthesis and key supporting evidence
The author concludes that sustainable resource management thrives when scientific governance aligns with localized economic stewardship, supported by data showing higher biomass and species richness.
The final sentence encapsulates the broader argument that ties together all supporting points in the text.
3
Evaluate the answer choices to identify the statement that captures the entire scope of the text without overgeneralizing or focusing on a single detail
The statement highlighting that co-management between artisanal guilds and scientists produces more resilient ecosystems than centralized bans accurately reflects the comprehensive main idea.
A main idea statement must encapsulate the entire passage rather than isolated procedural details or erroneous extremes.

Key Concept

Identifying Main Ideas and Supporting Details in Journalistic Texts
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Identifying Main Ideas and Supporting Details

More questions from this topic