Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumDistinguishing Fact from Opinion and Bias

Read the following editorial excerpt from a Michoacán newspaper concerning the expansion of avocado orchards near the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve:

"According to recent trade publications, avocado farming now occupies 150,000 hectares in the region, bringing in $2.5 billion in annual revenue. This economic miracle is undoubtedly the proudest achievement of our agricultural sector. However, this success is marred by ecological negligence. Satellite imagery confirms that forest cover has decreased by 10% since 2016, a loss directly endangering monarch butterfly habitats. The root of this crisis is the municipal administration's cowardice in refusing to challenge wealthy landowners. While some argue that small-scale farms are blame-free, the reality is that all commercial growers share equal responsibility for this environmental catastrophe."

Based on the editorial, which of the following statements represents a verifiable fact?

  1. A
    All commercial growers bear equal responsibility for the ecological damage.
  2. B
    The municipal administration's cowardice is the primary cause of the zoning crisis.
  3. Avocado cultivation in the region occupies 150,000 hectares.Answer
  4. D
    The growth of the avocado industry is the agricultural sector's proudest achievement.

Answer

Avocado cultivation in the region occupies 150,000 hectares.
The statement regarding avocado cultivation occupying 150,000 hectares is presented as an objective, verifiable statistic derived from trade publications, which makes it a fact.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage to identify sections containing objective data and statements expressing values, beliefs, or interpretations.
The text contains statistics (150,000 hectares, $2.5 billion, 10% forest loss) and subjective evaluations ('economic miracle', 'cowardice', 'equal responsibility').
Distinguishing objective data from subjective claims is the core step in separating fact from opinion.
2
Evaluate the statement about avocado cultivation occupying 150,000 hectares against the rest of the options.
The acreage statistic is a verifiable numerical fact. The other options make moral, qualitative, or causal judgments (blaming all growers, accusing the administration of cowardice, calling it the 'proudest achievement') which cannot be objectively verified.
Verifying which statement is supported by objective, quantifiable evidence determines the correct option.

Key Concept

Distinguishing objective, verifiable data (facts) from subjective judgments, interpretations, and biased claims (opinions) within a journalistic text.
Rate this question

Topics

Distinguishing Fact from Opinion and Bias

More questions from this topic