Question

Difficulty: EasyInferring Speaker Attitude and Tone

Read the following transcript of a conversation between a student and a professor:

Mateo: "Professor Álvarez, I was reviewing your notes on my initial research proposal. You mentioned that my topic was too broad, and I was worried I might need to choose an entirely new subject."

Professor Álvarez: "Not at all, Mateo. Your central hypothesis is fantastic and genuinely original! We simply need to narrow your case study to a single neighborhood rather than the entire metropolitan area. With that minor refinement, I am confident you will produce an outstanding final paper."

Mateo: "That is such a relief. I will implement those adjustments immediately. Thank you for the guidance!"

Based on the conversation, which of the following best describes Professor Álvarez's attitude toward Mateo's research proposal?

  1. A
    Skeptical and doubtful about the viability of the topic
  2. Encouraging and constructive regarding the project's potentialAnswer
  3. C
    Relieved and grateful that the revision will require minimal effort
  4. D
    Frustrated by the student's failure to follow original guidelines

Answer

Encouraging and constructive regarding the project's potential
The correct response accurately captures the professor's positive and supportive demeanour. Professor Álvarez explicitly commends Mateo's hypothesis as 'fantastic' and 'genuinely original' while offering practical, minor adjustments to narrow the scope, demonstrating confidence in the student's success.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Professor Álvarez's explicit statements and word choice regarding the student's proposal.
The professor uses positive evaluative language such as 'fantastic', 'genuinely original', and 'confident you will produce an outstanding final paper'.
Identifying evaluative adjectives and supportive phrasing provides direct evidence of the speaker's emotional stance and perspective.
2
Evaluate the nature of the feedback provided by the professor.
The professor provides actionable, targeted advice to narrow the scope to a single neighborhood rather than rejecting the project.
Offering constructive solutions while reassuring the student demonstrates a supportive and guiding attitude.
3
Synthesize the tonal evidence to determine the overall attitude.
The attitude is clearly encouraging and constructive.
Matching the evidence directly to the corresponding attitude description confirms the correct conclusion.

Key Concept

Inferring Speaker Attitude and Tone in Conversations
Rate this question