Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumJacksonian Democracy and the Second Party System

"The question is, shall we preserve that system under which we have risen to our present state of prosperity... or shall we abandon it, and return to a state of colonial dependency? [...] The tariff is not an intolerable burden; on the contrary, it is the very source of our national independence and internal wealth, binding the agricultural interest of the West with the manufacturing power of the North."
— Henry Clay, Speech in the U.S. Senate, February 1832

Based on the sentiments expressed in the excerpt, which of the following best describes the primary disagreement between the Whig Party and the Democratic Party over the policy advocated by Clay?

  1. A
    Whigs believed that the Supreme Court's decisions upholding federal economic power should be resisted by the states, while Democrats supported using the Marshall Court to enforce national economic policies.
  2. B
    Whigs opposed the expansion of the Market Revolution to protect local agricultural economies, while Democrats argued that federal tariffs were necessary to build urban factory systems in the South.
  3. Whigs argued that federal funding for internal improvements and protective tariffs would foster national economic development, while Democrats believed such measures unconstitutionally expanded federal power.Answer
  4. D
    Whigs advocated for strict construction of the Constitution to limit federal authority over trade, while Democrats supported loose construction to establish a national currency.

Answer

Whigs argued that federal funding for internal improvements and protective tariffs would foster national economic development, while Democrats believed such measures unconstitutionally expanded federal power.
The correct answer accurately describes the main economic debate of the Second Party System. The Whigs supported the American System, which used protective tariffs and federal infrastructure projects to integrate the Northern manufacturing and Western/Southern agricultural sectors. In contrast, Jacksonian Democrats opposed these policies on the grounds of strict constructionism, arguing that the Constitution did not grant the federal government the power to fund local improvements or favor one economic sector over another.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus to identify the speaker and key historical concept.
The excerpt is from Henry Clay's 1832 Senate speech defending the 'American System,' which relied on protective tariffs, a national bank, and federal funding for internal improvements.
Understanding the context of the stimulus is necessary to connect it to the platforms of the Second Party System.
2
Differentiate between the Whig and Democratic platforms regarding the American System.
The Whigs, led by figures like Henry Clay, championed these economic policies to promote national growth and integration. Jacksonian Democrats opposed them, arguing they exceeded constitutional limits on federal power and favored Northern commercial interests.
This differentiation allows for matching the historical debate in the excerpt to the correct option.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the statement that accurately represents each party's platform.
The option stating that Whigs favored federal intervention to foster integration while Democrats viewed it as unconstitutional is correct. Other options either reverse the parties' positions on constitutional interpretation, the Marshall Court, or the Market Revolution.
Comparing all options ensures that the selected answer is historically accurate and that distractors are correctly eliminated based on historical evidence.

Key Concept

The economic debates and platform differences between the Whigs and Democrats in the Second Party System.
Rate this question

Topics

Jacksonian Democracy and the Second Party System

More questions from this topic