Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumThe Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s

"We support the Administration's civil rights bill, but we support it with great reservations. It is true that we support the administration’s civil rights bill, but this bill will not protect young children and old women from police brutality. ... The voting section of this bill will not help the thousands of black people who want to vote, but who cannot do so because of the literacy tests and other voting qualifications in the Deep South. ... We must have a legislation that will protect the Mississippi sharecropper who is being evicted because he wants to register to vote."

— John Lewis, Chairman of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC), speech at the March on Washington, August 1963

The reservations about federal civil rights legislation expressed in the excerpt best reflect which of the following developments within the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s?

  1. A
    A universal consensus among activists that legislative lobbying was the only effective strategy for achieving racial equality.
  2. B
    The complete alignment of student-led organizations with the federal government's preferred timeline for gradual integration.
  3. Growing debates within the movement over whether to prioritize immediate, comprehensive federal protections or accept incremental legislative compromises.Answer
  4. D
    A decision by grassroots organizers to abandon direct action in favor of running candidates for local political offices.

Answer

The reservations about federal civil rights legislation expressed in the excerpt best reflect growing debates within the movement over whether to prioritize immediate, comprehensive federal protections or accept incremental legislative compromises.
The correct option is correct because John Lewis's speech highlights the frustration of younger, grassroots SNCC members with the limitations of the proposed federal civil rights bill, showcasing the strategic tension between those demanding immediate, radical changes and more moderate leaders who were willing to support the administration's compromise bill.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source document (John Lewis's 1963 speech) to identify the author's main point of contention.
The author expresses "great reservations" about the proposed federal civil rights bill, noting it fails to address police brutality, protect voting rights from literacy tests, or support evicted sharecroppers.
Understanding the specific limitations highlighted by the author helps identify the root of the debate.
2
Contextualize the author's organization (SNCC) within the broader Civil Rights Movement.
SNCC represented younger, more radical grassroots activists who pushed for immediate federal protection, contrasting with older, more moderate leaders who favored working within established political channels.
Placing the source in its historical context reveals the strategic divisions within the movement.
3
Evaluate the options to determine which dynamic is illustrated by these reservations.
The option describing growing debates over the limitations of federal reform and strategic differences is correct, while distractors incorrectly assume consensus or complete alignment.
This aligns with historical evidence of tactical and philosophical debates (challenging the consensus myth).

Key Concept

Internal philosophical and strategic debates within the Civil Rights Movement
Rate this question

Topics

The Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s

More questions from this topic