Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumWestward Expansion: Economic and Social Development

"The land laws now in force... are not well adapted to the conditions of the arid region. The homestead and preemption laws were designed for humid countries, where a farm of 80 or 160 acres is large enough... In the arid region, agriculture is not possible without irrigation... The development of these water resources requires cooperative labor or corporate capital in large amounts, far beyond the reach of the individual settler."
— John Wesley Powell, *Report on the Lands of the Arid Region of the United States*, 1878

The environmental and economic realities described in the excerpt most directly contributed to which of the following developments in the late nineteenth century?

  1. A
    The implementation of federal policies like the Dawes Act to preserve traditional Native American communal land rights.
  2. B
    The strict adherence to laissez-faire principles by the federal government in western economic development.
  3. The growing dominance of large-scale, corporate-financed farming operations in the far West.Answer
  4. D
    The immediate alliance of western farmers with urban, middle-class Progressive reformers to establish national labor unions.

Answer

The growing dominance of large-scale, corporate-financed farming operations in the far West.
The correct answer is correct because John Wesley Powell notes that the arid climate of the West made traditional 160-acre family farms unviable without irrigation. The heavy capital required to develop water systems and maintain farming operations in dry regions led directly to the consolidation of land and the rise of large-scale, corporate-financed agricultural businesses, commonly known as bonanza farms.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the historical context and the argument in the primary source.
In the excerpt, John Wesley Powell argues that the standard land distribution laws (such as the Homestead Act, which offered 160 acres) are unsuited to the dry conditions of the West, where farming is impossible without expensive irrigation infrastructure.
This establishes that the environmental limitations of the arid West rendered small-scale individual farming economically unviable.
2
Identify the economic consequence of these environmental constraints.
Because individual settlers lacked the capital to construct large-scale irrigation systems, agricultural production consolidated under corporate-financed enterprises (bonanza farms) that possessed the necessary resources.
This links the environmental reality to the Gilded Age trend of corporate consolidation in western industries.
3
Match this trend to the correct option.
The option noting the growing dominance of corporate-financed farming matches this historical outcome.
This identifies the correct development resulting from the mismatch between federal policy and environmental realities.

Key Concept

The consolidation of western agriculture and the limitations of traditional small-scale homesteading due to environmental conditions.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Westward Expansion: Economic and Social Development

More questions from this topic