Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumSouthern Economy, Society, and the Defense of Slavery

Source: William Gilmore Simms, Southern writer, *The Morals of Slavery*, 1837

'The negro has been civilized, socialized, and Christianized under the domestic institution of the South. In physical condition, he is incomparably better off than the voluntary laborer of Europe or the Northern states... Our system of society is a stable one, presenting a barrier to the levelling and radical doctrines that threaten the peace of free-labor societies where the interests of capital and labor are in constant conflict.'

The arguments expressed in the excerpt were most directly a response to which of the following historical developments?

  1. A
    The rapid industrialization of Southern cities, which created a large wage-labor class.
  2. The growth of a more confrontational and moralistic abolitionist movement in the North.Answer
  3. C
    The rising popularity of using white indentured servants instead of chattel slaves on plantations.
  4. D
    The economic transition of the South toward a self-sufficient manufacturing economy independent of Northern trade.

Answer

The growth of a more confrontational and moralistic abolitionist movement in the North.
The correct answer is correct because the rise of radical abolitionist sentiment in the North during the 1830s led Southern defenders of slavery to shift from viewing it as a 'necessary evil' to advocating for it as a 'positive good.' Southern writers like William Gilmore Simms argued that enslaved individuals were better off than Northern wage laborers, attempting to justify the institution in response to growing external moral critiques.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the author's argument in the provided primary source.
The author argues that Southern slavery is a stabilizing 'domestic institution' that benefits enslaved people more than free wage labor in the North, protecting society from 'radical doctrines.'
Understanding the author's thesis is the first step in identifying the historical context and the target of their counterarguments.
2
Identify the historical context of the late 1830s regarding debates over slavery.
During this period, Northern abolitionism was becoming increasingly organized, vocal, and moralistic (led by figures like William Lloyd Garrison), prompting an aggressive Southern ideological counteroffensive.
Connecting the document's date (1837) and its defensive, positive-good rhetoric to contemporary national debates reveals what the text is responding to.
3
Evaluate the options to find the development that prompted this defensive response.
The rise of Northern abolitionist moral attacks directly explains why Southern writers began defending slavery as a social and moral benefit, rather than a necessary evil.
Selecting the option that aligns with this cause-and-effect relationship identifies the correct historical development.

Key Concept

Southern Economy, Society, and the Defense of Slavery
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Southern Economy, Society, and the Defense of Slavery

More questions from this topic