Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumThe Great Society and the War on Poverty

Source: Sargent Shriver, Director of the Office of Economic Opportunity, testimony before the House Committee on Education and Labor, 1964.

"We are not trying to build a welfare state. We are trying to build an opportunity state. We are not trying to make the poor comfortable in their poverty. We are trying to help them get out of it... The Economic Opportunity Act does not guarantee anyone an income. It does guarantee them a chance to earn an income."

Based on the excerpt, in which of the following ways did the Great Society's approach to combating poverty differ most significantly from the domestic reforms of the New Deal?

  1. A
    It introduced the first federally funded social insurance programs like Social Security and unemployment compensation, whereas the New Deal focused on local community action.
  2. It focused on providing education, job training, and health services to increase individual opportunity rather than relying on direct public works employment and structural economic regulations.Answer
  3. C
    It sought to guarantee a minimum annual income and direct federal employment for all citizens, whereas the New Deal rejected direct federal relief.
  4. D
    It relied on state governments to administer and fund all major social programs, whereas the New Deal was managed entirely by centralized federal agencies.

Answer

The Great Society's War on Poverty focused on providing education, job training, and health services to increase individual opportunity rather than relying on direct public works employment and structural economic regulations.
The correct answer is correct because the War on Poverty, as part of Lyndon B. Johnson's Great Society, emphasized expanding opportunity through education (like Head Start), job training (like the Job Corps), and healthcare (Medicare and Medicaid), rather than creating direct federal employment programs (such as the WPA or CCC) or structural economic regulations that characterized the New Deal's response to the Great Depression. Shriver's focus on an 'opportunity state' rather than a 'welfare state' highlights this distinction.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus to identify the core argument and philosophy of the War on Poverty as described by Sargent Shriver.
Shriver emphasizes that the Economic Opportunity Act does not guarantee income but guarantees a 'chance to earn an income,' framing the War on Poverty as creating an 'opportunity state' rather than a 'welfare state' based on direct handouts.
Understanding the document's perspective is necessary to contrast it with other historical reform movements.
2
Recall the primary methods and programs of the New Deal in the 1930s.
The New Deal responded to the Great Depression by utilizing direct federal relief (cash assistance), creating massive public works employment programs (WPA, CCC, PWA), and establishing structural economic regulations (AAA, SEC, Glass-Steagall, Wagner Act).
Establishing the characteristics of the New Deal provides the basis for comparison.
3
Compare the Great Society's War on Poverty approach to the New Deal's approach to identify the primary difference.
The War on Poverty prioritized developmental assistance (education, job training, community action) to foster self-sufficiency and opportunity, contrasting with the New Deal's heavy reliance on direct job creation and regulatory reform.
This directly answers the prompt's question about how the two eras of reform differed in their approach to poverty.

Key Concept

Comparison between the New Deal and the Great Society's domestic reform strategies.
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

The Great Society and the War on Poverty

More questions from this topic