Question

Difficulty: Very hardEuropean Colonization Models

“Our interest is to unite ourselves with the savages... to live in friendship with them, and to bring them to knowledge of the true God. We must do this not by driving them from their lands, but by establishing trade and alliances, for without their hunting of the beaver, our commerce in this land would perish, and our settlements would have no means of support.”
— Memoir of a French colonial administrator at Montreal, 1687

Which of the following historical developments in the British North American colonies contrasted most directly with the French colonization model described in the passage?

  1. The establishment of permanent, family-based agricultural settlements that led to the displacement of Native American populationsAnswer
  2. B
    The reliance of New England colonial communities on large-scale tobacco cultivation utilizing indentured labor
  3. C
    The creation of imperial trade laws designed to encourage free enterprise and open commerce between the colonies and other European powers
  4. D
    The immediate and total replacement of indentured servants with chattel slaves upon the founding of the initial settlements

Answer

The establishment of permanent, family-based agricultural settlements that led to the displacement of Native American populations
The French colonization model focused on trade alliances, particularly the fur trade, and missionary work, which required maintaining cooperative relations with Native American populations. In contrast, British colonization was characterized by large-scale migration of families seeking land for agriculture. This focus on permanent agricultural settlement led the British to displace Native Americans from their lands, creating a system of social exclusion rather than integration.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the primary source passage to identify the key characteristics of the French colonization model described.
The passage emphasizes trade alliances (the beaver trade), missionary efforts, friendship, and avoiding the driving of Native Americans from their lands.
This establishes the baseline French model of colonization as trade-based and cooperative with indigenous populations.
2
Contrast the French model with the characteristics of British colonization in North America.
The British model focused heavily on agriculture, permanent family settlement, and land acquisition, which led to the exclusion and displacement of Native Americans.
This allows the student to identify the option that represents a direct historical contrast to the French model.
3
Evaluate the options to identify the correct contrast and eliminate the distractors.
The option describing permanent agricultural settlements and displacement is correct, while the other options represent historical inaccuracies or misconceptions regarding mercantilism, regional differences, or labor systems.
This confirms the correct option based on historical evidence and eliminates plausible distractors.

Key Concept

French and British Colonization Models
Rate this question