Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumResistance to Reconstruction and its Ultimate Collapse

"We demand the immediate and absolute removal of all disabilities imposed on account of the Rebellion, in the conviction that universal amnesty will result in complete pacification in all sections of the country; and we believe that local self-government... will guard the rights of all citizens more securely than any centralized power."

— Platform of the Liberal Republican Party, 1872

Which of the following historical developments was the most direct consequence of the political trend reflected in the excerpt?

  1. A
    The initiation of Radical Reconstruction policies and the impeachment of President Andrew Johnson
  2. B
    The revival of popular sovereignty to determine the legal status of labor systems in newly organized Western territories
  3. The erosion of Northern political resolve to sustain federal military intervention and protect freedmen's rights in the SouthAnswer
  4. D
    The drafting and ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment to define federal citizenship and protect individual rights

Answer

The erosion of Northern political resolve to sustain federal military intervention and protect freedmen's rights in the South
The correct answer is correct because the rise of the Liberal Republican faction in 1872 reflected a broader shift in Northern public opinion away from federal military intervention in the South. By advocating for the removal of political restrictions on former Confederates and emphasizing local self-government over federal oversight, this political trend directly undermined the political support required to sustain Radical Reconstruction, leading to the eventual return of Southern states to Democratic control.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source document
The document is the 1872 Platform of the Liberal Republican Party. Key phrases include the demand for the removal of political disabilities on former Confederates ('universal amnesty') and a preference for 'local self-government' over 'centralized power.'
Understanding the source's main argument is necessary to trace its historical consequences.
2
Contextualize the source within Reconstruction history
By 1872, many Northerners were experiencing 'Reconstruction fatigue' and wanted to move on from Southern affairs. The Liberal Republicans split from the main Republican Party, challenging President Grant's use of federal troops to enforce civil rights laws.
This places the document within the chronological decline of Northern commitment to protecting freedmen.
3
Identify the direct consequence of this political trend
The demand for local control and amnesty directly contributed to the abandonment of federal protection for freedmen, the rise of Redeemer Democrats in the South, and the ultimate withdrawal of federal troops following the Compromise of 1877.
This links the ideology of the Liberal Republicans to the collapse of Reconstruction.

Key Concept

The decline of federal commitment to Reconstruction due to political shifts and waning Northern resolve.
Rate this question

Topics

Resistance to Reconstruction and its Ultimate Collapse

More questions from this topic