Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardEnvironmentalism and the Energy Crisis

"We are locked in a struggle between two conflicting national goals: the demand for more energy to keep our factories running and our cars moving, and the demand for a cleaner environment. . . . The environmental protection movement has succeeded in passing laws that require complex environmental impact statements for every new project. The resulting red tape and litigation have delayed the Trans-Alaska pipeline, blocked offshore drilling, and stalled nuclear power development. If we do not find a way to balance these goals, the energy crisis will become a permanent feature of American life, leading to economic stagnation."
—Mobil Oil Corporation advertisement, *The New York Times*, 1974

The arguments presented in the advertisement most directly reflect which of the following broader conflicts in United States history during the 1970s?

  1. The conflict between the expansion of federal environmental regulation and the demands for domestic energy development.Answer
  2. B
    The implementation of supply-side economic policies that mandated strict conservation targets for private corporations.
  3. C
    The sudden abandonment of long-standing nineteenth-century laissez-faire policies that had entirely prohibited federal intervention in resource management.
  4. D
    A major shift in Cold War containment doctrine that prioritized environmental protection over international security alliances.

Answer

The conflict between the expansion of federal environmental regulation and the demands for domestic energy development.
The advertisement represents the reaction of corporate and industrial interests to the growth of environmental laws in the late 1960s and 1970s. Faced with fuel shortages and economic stagnation during the energy crisis, industry groups argued that federal regulations—such as environmental impact statements required by the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)—were stalling energy independence and hurting the economy. This illustrates the central conflict of the era between environmental protection and energy/economic goals.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided advertisement's main argument and context.
The source is a 1974 Mobil Oil advertisement expressing concern over environmental regulations delaying energy projects (like pipelines and drilling) during the energy crisis.
Understanding the source's viewpoint is necessary to connect it to the correct historical conflict.
2
Evaluate the options against the historical context of the mid-1970s.
The conflict between the expansion of federal environmental regulation and the demands for domestic energy development correctly identifies the central debate between environmental laws (like NEPA) and the push for domestic energy production.
Connecting the specific complaints in the passage (environmental impact statements delaying energy projects) to the broader thematic conflict between environmental protection and energy/economic goals is the target of the question.
3
Verify why the distractors are incorrect based on the error taxonomy.
The other options misrepresent supply-side economics, mischaracterize nineteenth-century federal land policies, or incorrectly link Cold War containment to environmental policy.
Ensuring that the distractors are historically inaccurate or conceptually flawed confirms the validity of the single correct answer.

Key Concept

Environmentalism and the Energy Crisis
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Environmentalism and the Energy Crisis

More questions from this topic