Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardCivil War Military Mobilization and Strategy

"I think, therefore, we must decide whether slavery shall be extinguished by our enemies and the slaves be used against us, or use them ourselves at the risk of the effects which must be produced upon our social institutions. My own opinion is that we should employ them without delay. I believe that with proper regulations they can be made efficient soldiers... We should not expect slaves to fight for their servitude... [We should] give immediate freedom to all who enlist, and to their families..."

—General Robert E. Lee, Confederate States Army, letter to Andrew Hunter, January 11, 1865

Which of the following best explains why the Confederacy delayed implementing the strategy proposed in the excerpt until the final months of the war?

  1. The proposal directly undermined the foundational ideological justification of the Confederacy, which was the preservation and defense of slavery.Answer
  2. B
    Most Confederate leaders believed that the war was fought primarily over tariff disputes and economic policy, making the status of slaves irrelevant to the war effort.
  3. C
    Southern politicians insisted that the principle of popular sovereignty required individual territories, rather than the Confederate central government, to decide the status of enslaved soldiers.
  4. D
    Confederate mobilization relied instead on reviving colonial-era indentured servitude contracts for European immigrants to fill military ranks.

Answer

The proposal directly undermined the foundational ideological justification of the Confederacy, which was the preservation and defense of slavery.
The correct answer is correct because the Confederacy was established with the primary goal of preserving and defending chattel slavery. Offering freedom to enslaved people in exchange for military service undermined the core social and racial hierarchies that Southern leaders fought to protect. Because this proposal contradicted their fundamental war aims, Confederate leaders debated and resisted the enlistment of enslaved soldiers until the spring of 1865, when military collapse was inevitable.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the historical source and its timing.
The excerpt is from a letter by General Robert E. Lee in January 1865 advocating for the enlistment and emancipation of enslaved African Americans.
This establishes that the Confederacy was considering a radical policy change during the desperate final months of the Civil War.
2
Connect the policy proposal to Confederate ideology.
Providing freedom to enslaved soldiers directly contradicted the fundamental premise of the Confederacy—preserving chattel slavery.
This explains the intense resistance and long delay in implementing the policy.
3
Select the correct option based on ideological conflict.
The option stating that the proposal undermined the preservation of slavery is selected.
This option accurately explains why Confederate authorities resisted the measure until defeat was imminent.

Key Concept

Civil War Military Mobilization and Strategy
Rate this question

Topics

Civil War Military Mobilization and Strategy

More questions from this topic