Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumJeffersonian Presidency and Territorial Expansion

“The purchase of Louisiana is a subject of great importance... The possession of New Orleans and the Floridas was indeed essential to our peace and security... But as to the unlimited region west of the Mississippi, its acquisition is of very questionable utility. It will tend to scatter our population, to weaken our government, by making it more difficult to enforce the laws over so wide a space, and to accelerate the division of the Union.”
—Alexander Hamilton, *New-York Evening Post*, July 1803

Which of the following Jeffersonian principles is most directly challenged by Hamilton’s argument in the excerpt?

  1. The belief that territorial expansion would secure an "empire of liberty" by providing land for agrarian citizens.Answer
  2. B
    The stance that the federal government must strictly adhere to the powers explicitly listed in the Constitution.
  3. C
    The advocacy for developing domestic manufacturing and commerce to achieve national self-sufficiency.
  4. D
    The effort to limit the authority of the federal judiciary through political opposition to judicial appointments.

Answer

The belief that territorial expansion would secure an "empire of liberty" by providing land for agrarian citizens.
The correct option is correct because Thomas Jefferson's primary justification for territorial expansion was the creation of an "empire of liberty." He believed that a large republic of independent, land-owning farmers was necessary to prevent the urban decay, dependency, and corruption associated with European-style industrialization. Hamilton's argument that expanding the nation's borders would scatter the population and weaken the federal government's authority directly challenges this agrarian expansionist vision.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus excerpt by Alexander Hamilton from 1803.
Hamilton expresses concern that the vast territory acquired west of the Mississippi will scatter the population, weaken the authority of the central government, and potentially divide the Union.
Understanding the core argument of the Federalist critic is necessary to identify which Democratic-Republican (Jeffersonian) goal it opposes.
2
Recall the primary goals and beliefs of Thomas Jefferson regarding territorial expansion.
Jefferson envisioned the United States as an "empire of liberty," where continuous expansion would provide land for a growing population of independent, agrarian citizens, thereby preserving republican democracy.
Identifying the target Jeffersonian principle allows for a direct comparison with Hamilton's critique.
3
Compare the options to determine which Jeffersonian principle is directly challenged by Hamilton’s focus on the dangers of population dispersion and weakened governance.
Hamilton's concern about scattering the population directly contradicts Jefferson's vision of expanding the republic to support agrarian settlement.
This establishes the correct option based on direct ideological opposition.

Key Concept

Jeffersonian Expansionism versus Federalist Consolidationism
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Jeffersonian Presidency and Territorial Expansion

More questions from this topic