Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardSouthern Economy, Society, and the Defense of Slavery

“Compare the easy, light, and healthy labor of the slave with that of the Northern factory operative or the European peasant, who is struggling with poverty, hunger, and cold, and tell me who is the true slave. The southern slave is secure of a comfortable maintenance during life, in infancy, sickness, and old age... The institution of slavery is a necessary and indispensable element in all highly civilized communities.”
— Chancellor William Harper, *Memoir on Slavery*, 1837

The arguments expressed in the excerpt were most directly a reaction to which of the following developments?

  1. The growth of the abolitionist movement and increasing moral condemnation of slavery from Northern reformers.Answer
  2. B
    The rapid industrialization of the Southern economy, which led planters to shift enslaved labor from agricultural fields to textile factories.
  3. C
    The legislative transition from temporary white indentured servitude to permanent, race-based chattel slavery.
  4. D
    The total economic independence of the Southern states, which severed all trade ties with Northern merchants and manufacturers.

Answer

The arguments expressed in the excerpt were most directly a reaction to the growth of the abolitionist movement and increasing moral condemnation of slavery from Northern reformers.
The correct answer is correct because the 'positive good' argument—which compared enslaved labor favorably to Northern wage labor—emerged in the 1830s primarily as a defensive response to the growth of militant Northern abolitionism and reform movements that criticized the morality of slavery.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source and historical context of the excerpt.
The excerpt is from Chancellor William Harper's *Memoir on Slavery* in 1837, arguing that slavery is a 'necessary and indispensable element' of civilized society and comparing enslaved labor to Northern factory workers.
Identifying the author's viewpoint and date establishes that this text is part of the antebellum 'positive good' defense of slavery.
2
Identify the primary cause for the emergence of the 'positive good' defense in the 1830s.
Prior to the 1830s, Southern leaders often described slavery as a 'necessary evil.' The shift to defending it as a 'positive good' was a response to the rise of militant Northern abolitionism (e.g., William Lloyd Garrison's *The Liberator* in 1831) and organized moral reform movements.
This links the ideological defense of slavery directly to the external reform pressures the South faced.
3
Evaluate the distractors against historical evidence from the period 1800-1848.
The transition from indentured servitude occurred in the colonial era (Period 2), and the South did not industrialize or isolate itself from Northern markets during the Market Revolution; instead, they were economically interdependent.
Evaluating the distractors rules out incorrect chronologies and economic misconceptions.

Key Concept

The Southern ideological defense of slavery ('positive good' argument) developed in the 1830s as a reaction to rising Northern abolitionist criticism and the economic integration of the cotton kingdom.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Southern Economy, Society, and the Defense of Slavery

More questions from this topic