Question

Difficulty: MediumResistance to Reconstruction and its Ultimate Collapse

"The Fifteenth Amendment does not confer the right of suffrage upon any one. It prevents the States, or the United States, however, from giving preference, in this particular, to one citizen of the United States over another on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude. Before its adoption, this could be done. It was as much within the power of a State to exclude citizens of the United States from voting on account of race... as it was on account of age, property, or education. Now it is not."

—United States Supreme Court, *United States v. Reese* (1876)

Based on the passage, which of the following was a direct historical consequence of the Supreme Court's ruling?

  1. The implementation of state-level voting restrictions, such as literacy tests, that did not explicitly mention raceAnswer
  2. B
    The passage of the Enforcement Acts by Congress to curb white supremacist violence at voting places
  3. C
    The strengthening of the Fourteenth Amendment’s equal protection clause in Southern states
  4. D
    A broad expansion of federal authority over state-level voter registration policies

Answer

The implementation of state-level voting restrictions, such as literacy tests, that did not explicitly mention race
The correct answer is correct because the Supreme Court's ruling in *United States v. Reese* established a narrow reading of the Fifteenth Amendment, stating it did not confer suffrage but only prohibited discrimination based on race. This allowed Southern states to circumvent the amendment by implementing non-racial voting barriers, such as literacy tests, poll taxes, and grandfather clauses, effectively disenfranchising African American voters and dismantling Reconstruction-era political gains.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the historical context and main argument of the Supreme Court excerpt from *United States v. Reese* (1876).
The Court asserts that the Fifteenth Amendment does not guarantee anyone the right to vote; it only prohibits states from using race, color, or previous servitude as a basis for denying the vote.
Understanding the Court's narrow interpretation of the Fifteenth Amendment is crucial to predicting its historical effects.
2
Connect this narrow legal interpretation to the actions of Southern state governments during the collapse of Reconstruction.
Southern Democrats (Redeemers) realized they could disenfranchise African Americans using criteria other than race, such as literacy, property ownership, or poll taxes.
This links the legal precedent set by the Court to the subsequent political and social realities in the South.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that matches this consequence.
The option describing the implementation of state-level voting barriers like literacy tests directly reflects how Southern states exploited this ruling's loophole.
This identifies the correct option based on historical cause and effect.

Key Concept

The role of the federal judiciary in weakening Reconstruction and enabling Southern disenfranchisement
Rate this question