Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardThe Articles of Confederation and the Northwest Territory

"The British cabinet... constantly repeat the complaints of British merchants, that the courts of justice in several of the States are shut against them... and that the recovery of old debts is obstructed by state laws... They ask, and they have a right to ask, whether the Congress has power to enforce the treaties they make? While the individual States can pass laws that defeat the national engagements, we shall never be respected by foreign powers, nor will Great Britain evacuate the western military posts."

—John Adams, Minister to Great Britain, letter to the Secretary for Foreign Affairs, 1785

Which of the following developments was a direct consequence of the concerns expressed in the excerpt?

  1. The growing movement among nationalist political leaders to revise the Articles of Confederation and strengthen the central government's authority.Answer
  2. B
    The establishment of a federal court system under the Articles of Confederation to resolve disputes between states and foreign creditors.
  3. C
    The immediate passage of a uniform national tariff by the Confederation Congress to retaliate against British trade restrictions.
  4. D
    The alignment of the Federalist and Democratic-Republican parties over the scope of executive power in foreign policy.

Answer

The concerns in the excerpt most directly contributed to the growing movement among nationalist political leaders to revise the Articles of Confederation and strengthen the central government's authority.
The correct option explains that the weakness of the central government under the Articles of Confederation, specifically its inability to enforce treaty provisions or compel states to comply with international agreements, created severe foreign policy crises. These issues, combined with domestic economic instability, convinced nationalist leaders of the need to reform the national government, ultimately leading to the Constitutional Convention of 1787.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source document to identify the key arguments and complaints.
John Adams notes that the British refuse to evacuate western military posts because American states are passing laws that block British merchants from recovering pre-war debts, thereby violating the Treaty of Paris.
Understanding the source is necessary to identify the core weakness of the Articles of Confederation highlighted by the author.
2
Recall the structural limitations of the Articles of Confederation regarding treaty enforcement and national power.
Under the Articles, the national government had no independent judiciary to strike down state laws that violated treaties, and it lacked the power to compel states to pay debts or comply with foreign agreements.
Connecting the document to the historical limits of the Articles allows for identifying the broader political context.
3
Identify the primary political consequence of these unresolved foreign policy and debt crises in the late 1780s.
These weaknesses convinced nationalists (like James Madison and Alexander Hamilton) that the Articles of Confederation were fundamentally flawed and needed to be replaced, leading directly to the Constitutional Convention.
Finding the option that matches this historical progression yields the correct answer.

Key Concept

The structural weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation in foreign relations and treaty enforcement.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

The Articles of Confederation and the Northwest Territory

More questions from this topic