Question

Difficulty: MediumJackson and Federal Power Conflicts

“We are in the midst of a revolution, hitherto bloodless, but rapidly tending towards a total change of the pure republican character of the Government, and to the concentration of all power in the hands of one man. The vertical partition of power, between the State Governments and the General Government, and the horizontal distribution of it among the three departments of the latter, have both been shaken and disturbed.”
— Senator Henry Clay, speech in the United States Senate, December 26, 1833

The sentiments expressed in the excerpt were most directly a response to which of the following actions by the Jackson administration?

  1. A
    The Supreme Court rulings under Chief Justice John Marshall that declared the national bank unconstitutional
  2. The unilateral executive order to remove federal deposits from the Second Bank of the United StatesAnswer
  3. C
    The federal government's refusal to intervene in state-level labor strikes and industrial disputes
  4. D
    The implementation of a national tariff designed to fund infrastructure projects under the Articles of Confederation

Answer

The unilateral executive order to remove federal deposits from the Second Bank of the United States
The correct answer is correct because Henry Clay’s speech was delivered in direct response to President Andrew Jackson’s decision to remove federal funds from the Second Bank of the United States without congressional approval. Whigs viewed this as a dangerous expansion of executive authority at the expense of the legislative branch.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the primary source excerpt to identify the speaker's main concern.
The speaker (Henry Clay) is criticizing the concentration of power in 'one man' (the Executive branch) and the disruption of the balance of power ('horizontal distribution').
Understanding the tone and core argument of the stimulus is necessary to connect it to the correct historical context.
2
Identify the specific historical context of Henry Clay's speech in December 1833.
The speech was delivered during the 'Bank War' in late 1833, specifically after Andrew Jackson ordered the removal of federal deposits from the Second Bank of the United States.
This connects the political rhetoric of executive overreach to the actual policy action that triggered the speech.
3
Evaluate the options to find the one that matches this historical context and avoids common misconceptions.
The option regarding the unilateral executive removal of federal deposits is the correct match, while other options are chronologically or conceptually incorrect.
Evaluating all options ensures that distractors based on misconceptions about the Marshall Court, Gilded Age, or the Articles of Confederation are eliminated.

Key Concept

Debates over federal and executive authority during the Jacksonian Era
Estimated Time:1m 0s
Rate this question