Question

Difficulty: HardInterwar Foreign Policy and Road to World War II

"It seems to be unfortunately true that the epidemic of world lawlessness is spreading. When an epidemic of physical disease starts to spread, the community approves and joins in a quarantine of the patients in order to protect the health of the community against the spread of the disease. . . . We are determined to keep out of war, yet we cannot insure ourselves against the disastrous effects of war and the dangers of involvement."
— President Franklin D. Roosevelt, Chicago address, 1937

Which of the following historical developments during the late 1930s best explains the domestic political conflict surrounding the ideas expressed in the excerpt?

  1. An attempt by the executive branch to challenge prevailing isolationist sentiment and advocate for collective securityAnswer
  2. B
    A shift toward absolute isolationism, resulting in the total suspension of all US trade and diplomatic relations with European nations
  3. C
    The formal abandonment of the Monroe Doctrine in order to establish military alliances with democratic European powers
  4. D
    The immediate implementation of the Lend-Lease program to provide direct military support to nations resisting aggression

Answer

An attempt by the executive branch to challenge prevailing isolationist sentiment and advocate for collective security
The correct option is the one stating that the excerpt reflects an effort by the executive branch to challenge prevailing isolationist sentiment and promote collective security. In his 1937 Chicago address, Roosevelt used the metaphor of a quarantine to suggest that international lawlessness could not be ignored and that peaceful nations must cooperate to contain aggression. This stood in sharp contrast to the prevailing isolationist sentiment of the era, which was codified in the Neutrality Acts.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus context, author, and date
The stimulus is a speech by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1937 (known as the 'Quarantine Speech') advocating for a 'quarantine' of lawless nations.
Understanding the source and historical moment helps identify the political tensions between the executive branch's internationalist inclinations and the isolationist public sentiment.
2
Evaluate the political climate of the late 1930s regarding foreign policy
The mid-to-late 1930s were dominated by isolationist sentiment, manifested in the passage of the Neutrality Acts to prevent U.S. involvement in foreign conflicts.
This establishes the baseline domestic policy that FDR was challenging with his call for collective security.
3
Assess the options to find which development best explains the conflict over the speech
FDR was trying to challenge the dominant isolationist consensus by suggesting collective action, which provoked an immediate backlash from isolationists in Congress and the public.
This directly answers the prompt's question about the nature of the domestic political conflict.

Key Concept

The tension between isolationist sentiment and the executive branch's shift toward collective security in the late 1930s.
Rate this question