Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardCauses of the Great Depression

"If orgies of unrestrained speculation are permitted to spread, the ultimate collapse is certain to affect not only the speculators themselves, but also the entire country... The index of industrial share prices has ceased to bear any relationship to the earnings of the enterprises they represent, and the diversion of credit from productive enterprise to the call money market threatens the stability of our entire banking system."
— Paul M. Warburg, International Acceptance Bank annual report, March 1929

Based on the excerpt and your knowledge of the period, which of the following statements best describes how the development warned against by Warburg contributed to the onset of the Great Depression?

  1. A
    It forced the federal government to abandon its pro-business policies and dismantle the protective tariffs that had previously insulated domestic agriculture.
  2. B
    It was driven by a complete withdrawal of United States financial institutions from foreign markets, isolating the domestic economy from international trade.
  3. It created an unstable financial environment where asset values were inflated by easy credit, making the economy highly vulnerable to a sudden contraction in investor confidence.Answer
  4. D
    It prompted the immediate passage of early New Deal legislation that inflated the currency and directly caused the bank runs of late 1929.

Answer

The correct answer is that speculation and easy credit created an unstable financial environment where asset values were inflated, leaving the economy highly vulnerable to a sudden loss of investor confidence.
The correct option is correct because the rapid expansion of credit and margin buying in the 1920s allowed speculators to inflate stock prices far beyond the actual earnings of corporations. This speculation made the financial sector highly fragile, so when investor confidence fell in late 1929, the panic triggered a chain reaction of bank failures and credit contraction that spread throughout the entire economy.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the source text to identify the core economic warning.
The author warns that unrestrained speculation and the diversion of credit to the stock market ('call money market') have inflated stock prices beyond their actual earnings, threatening banking stability.
Understanding the author's argument is necessary to connect the stimulus to the broader causes of the Great Depression.
2
Connect the warning about speculation and credit to the systemic causes of the Great Depression.
The reliance on credit for buying stocks (buying on margin) created an asset bubble. When stock prices began to fall, brokers called in loans, leading to forced sales, a rapid decline in asset values, and widespread bank failures.
Connecting the stimulus to the historical context explains the causal mechanism of the economic collapse.
3
Evaluate the options to find the one that accurately describes this economic vulnerability while avoiding historical misconceptions.
The correct statement notes that easy credit inflated asset values and made the economy vulnerable to a collapse in investor confidence. Other options contain historical inaccuracies regarding the timeline of the New Deal, the nature of 1920s tariff policies, or the degree of US international economic engagement.
Applying historical knowledge to eliminate incorrect claims ensures the selection of the correct option.

Key Concept

Credit expansion, speculative bubbles, and banking vulnerabilities in the 1920s as primary causes of the Great Depression.
Rate this question

Topics

Causes of the Great Depression

More questions from this topic