Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardRise of Industrial Capitalism and Business Consolidation

"If the concerted powers of this combination are entrusted to a single man or can be played under the control of a wealthy association, their power for evil will be increased, and it is not too much to say that they will control the Government itself... If we will not endure a king as a political power we should not endure a king over the production, transportation, and sale of any of the necessaries of life. If we would not submit to an emperor we should not submit to an autocrat of trade, with power to prevent competition and to fix the price of any commodity."
— Senator John Sherman, speech in the United States Senate, 1890

Which of the following government policies during the late nineteenth century most directly contributed to the power and growth of the 'wealthy association[s]' criticized in the excerpt?

  1. A
    The reinforcement of colonial-era mercantilist policies designed to maintain a favorable balance of trade with European nations.
  2. B
    The strict adherence to a laissez-faire philosophy that prevented the federal government from intervening in or aiding private business.
  3. The provision of federal land subsidies and high protective tariffs that insulated domestic industries from foreign competition.Answer
  4. D
    The immediate enactment of Progressive Era reforms, such as the graduated income tax, to redistribute corporate profits.

Answer

The provision of federal land subsidies and high protective tariffs that insulated domestic industries from foreign competition.
The correct answer is correct because the federal government during the Gilded Age actively intervened in the economy to support industrial consolidation. This support came in the form of substantial land grants and subsidies to railroad corporations, as well as high protective tariffs that shielded domestic manufacturers from foreign competition, allowing large trusts to dominate the market.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus context.
The excerpt is from a speech by Senator John Sherman in 1890, warning against the political and economic power of large business combinations, trusts, and monopolies that control production and prices.
Understanding the source of criticism helps identify the industrial consolidation and corporate power characteristic of the Gilded Age.
2
Evaluate the relationship between late-nineteenth-century businesses and the federal government.
Identify that while industrial capitalists championed laissez-faire ideology to prevent regulation, they welcomed and lobbied for government intervention that aided their expansion.
This step distinguishes the myth of pure laissez-faire from the reality of government economic intervention.
3
Identify specific government interventions that supported consolidation.
The federal government provided direct economic assistance through massive Pacific Railway land grants, financial subsidies, and high protective tariffs (such as the McKinley Tariff).
This matches the historical reality of how corporate monopolies established dominance with government aid.
4
Eliminate incorrect options.
Mercantilism is chronologically incorrect. Strict laissez-faire is a historical misconception because government actively aided business. Progressive reforms are chronologically incorrect as they occurred in the early twentieth century.
This confirms that the only historically accurate and contextually appropriate answer is the option regarding subsidies and tariffs.

Key Concept

Rise of Industrial Capitalism and Business Consolidation
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Rise of Industrial Capitalism and Business Consolidation

More questions from this topic