Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumThe New South and Jim Crow

"The old South rested on slavery and agriculture, and the new South presents a perfect democracy, the oligarchs leading in the popular movement; a social system compact and unitary, the millions of blacks succeeding to the franchise... and a diversified system of agriculture and industry... We have sowed towns and cities in the place of theories, and put business above politics."

— Henry W. Grady, editor of the *Atlanta Constitution*, "The New South" speech, 1886

Which of the following economic developments in the late nineteenth-century South most directly contradicted the assertions made by Grady in the excerpt?

  1. A
    The implementation of strict laissez-faire policies by the federal government that prevented any public support for railway construction in the South.
  2. B
    The formation of the Populist Party, which drew its core support from urban middle-class reformers and factory owners in Southern cities.
  3. The persistence of a sharecropping system that kept the region predominantly agricultural and trapped many laborers in a cycle of debt.Answer
  4. D
    The enactment of the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments, which established legal citizenship and voting rights.

Answer

The persistence of a sharecropping system that kept the region predominantly agricultural and trapped many laborers in a cycle of debt.
The correct answer is the option describing the persistence of the sharecropping system. Although proponents of the 'New South' like Henry Grady envisioned a diversified economy with rapid industrialization and urban growth, the post-Civil War South remained overwhelmingly agrarian. Sharecropping and tenant farming dominated the Southern economy, keeping millions of Black and white farmers tied to the land in a cycle of debt and poverty, which directly contradicted Grady's optimistic claims of a diversified economy and black prosperity.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main argument of the stimulus.
Henry Grady argues that the 'New South' has successfully transitioned to a diversified economy of agriculture and industry with democratic participation for Black citizens.
Understanding the speaker's claims is necessary to determine what historical evidence would contradict them.
2
Analyze the actual economic conditions of the late nineteenth-century South.
The South remained economically underdeveloped compared to the North, with most of the population engaged in tenant farming and sharecropping rather than industrial manufacturing.
This provides the historical context needed to evaluate the validity of Grady's claims.
3
Evaluate which option presents a historical development that directly contradicts the claims of diversification and prosperity.
The sharecropping system restricted economic mobility and kept the South agricultural, contradicting the New South vision.
This identifies the correct answer by matching historical evidence against the stimulus claims.

Key Concept

The economic realities of the New South, specifically the sharecropping system and its impact on the region's industrialization goals.
Rate this question

Topics

The New South and Jim Crow

More questions from this topic