Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumSouthern Economy, Society, and the Defense of Slavery

"In a slaveholding community, the white man, however poor or humble, is a member of the ruling class. He is equal to the wealthiest planter. Color, not wealth, is the mark of distinction, and the poorest white citizen feels that he belongs to an elevated caste, sharing in the dignity and privileges of the dominant race. This creates a bond of union among whites that transcends all differences of property or education, rendering our society remarkably stable..."

— Adapted from Thomas R. Dew, Review of the Debate in the Virginia Legislature, 1832

Which of the following developments during the early nineteenth century best explains the social dynamic described in the excerpt?

  1. A
    The growth of industrial manufacturing in Southern cities, which provided high-wage factory jobs for poor white laborers.
  2. B
    The replacement of hereditary chattel slavery with temporary indentured contracts to pacify labor unrest among poor whites.
  3. The creation of a shared racial identity and social hierarchy that united non-slaveholding whites with the planter elite.Answer
  4. D
    The resolution of sectional conflicts through federal tariff reductions, which eliminated economic divisions between classes.

Answer

The creation of a shared racial identity and social hierarchy that united non-slaveholding whites with the planter elite.
The correct answer is correct because Thomas Dew's argument highlights how racial hierarchy and white supremacy created solidarity among white southerners across different economic classes. By emphasizing color over wealth as the primary mark of distinction, the planter elite fostered a shared identity that bound non-slaveholding yeoman farmers to the defense of the plantation economy and chattel slavery, even though they did not directly own slaves.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus passage to identify the central argument.
The author argues that in the South, racial status ('color') is more important than wealth in determining social standing, which creates a bond of equality and stability among all white citizens regardless of their property.
This establishes the historical context of the Southern social hierarchy and the defense of slavery.
2
Link the argument in the passage to the broader historical developments of the Southern economy and society between 1800 and 1848.
Recognize that the planter class maintained hegemony and social stability by promoting a racial ideology of white supremacy, which aligned the interests of the non-slaveholding majority (yeoman farmers) with the slaveholding elite.
This identifies the historical mechanism that explains the social dynamic of white solidarity in the antebellum South.
3
Evaluate the answer choices to find the one that best matches this historical reality and rule out incorrect options based on economic and social facts of the period.
The option highlighting a shared racial identity is correct, while options suggesting Southern industrial growth, the return of indentured servitude, or class harmony through tariff reductions are historically inaccurate.
This confirms the correct option while identifying the misconceptions in the distractors.

Key Concept

The social structure and ideological defense of slavery in the antebellum South
Rate this question

Topics

Southern Economy, Society, and the Defense of Slavery

More questions from this topic