Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPhilosophical Foundations of the American Revolution

Read the excerpt below.

"The end of government being the good of mankind, points out its great duties: It is above all things to provide for the security, the quiet, and happy enjoyment of life, liberty, and property. There is no one act which a government can perform, that is not to be tested by this standard. . . . These are the first principles of law and justice, and the great barriers of a free state, and of the British constitution in particular. To say that the parliament has a right to tax the colonies, is to say they have a right to take away their money, or their property, without their consent."
— James Otis, *The Rights of the British Colonies Asserted and Proved*, 1764

The ideas expressed in the excerpt most directly contributed to which of the following colonial arguments against British imperial policy?

  1. A
    The immediate demand for complete separation and independence from Great Britain following the end of the Seven Years' War.
  2. The assertion that Parliament could not legitimately tax colonists without their consent because it violated their natural rights to property.Answer
  3. C
    The proposal to establish a centralized federal government with the power to levy national taxes and regulate interstate commerce.
  4. D
    The belief that a national bank was necessary to manage colonial currency and stabilize the transatlantic economy.

Answer

The assertion that Parliament could not legitimately tax colonists without their consent because it violated their natural rights to property.
The correct answer is correct because the excerpt directly applies Enlightenment principles of natural rights and the social contract—specifically the protection of life, liberty, and property—to argue that parliamentary taxation without colonial consent was illegitimate. By referencing 'life, liberty, and property' and asserting that taking money without consent violates the first principles of law, Otis established a philosophical justification that became central to the colonial resistance against British acts like the Stamp Act and Townshend Acts.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus text to identify its core philosophical argument.
The author (James Otis) references 'life, liberty, and property' as the standard for government actions and argues that taxing colonists without consent violates these first principles.
This establishes that the passage is rooted in Enlightenment political theory, specifically John Locke's ideas regarding natural rights and the social contract.
2
Relate these philosophical principles to the historical context of the American Revolution.
During the early colonial resistance (circa 1764), colonists utilized Locke's ideas to argue that since they were not represented in Parliament, Parliament could not rightfully tax them, as doing so violated their natural rights to property.
This links the intellectual foundation of the Enlightenment to the specific political grievances of the colonists regarding imperial taxation.
3
Evaluate the options to select the one that represents the direct historical development or argument stemming from these ideas, and rule out incorrect options.
The option asserting that Parliament could not tax without consent due to natural rights directly matches the analysis. Other options represent ideas from later periods (the 1780s and 1790s) or mischaracterize the 1764 political goals (demanding immediate independence).
This confirms the correct option while identifying the chronological and thematic errors in the distractors.

Key Concept

The application of Enlightenment principles, particularly Locke's social contract and natural rights (life, liberty, and property), to argue against British imperial taxation without colonial representation.

Hints

1
Identify the key political philosopher whose ideas ('life, liberty, and property') are echoed in the opening lines of the excerpt.

Practice More

Review how these Lockean principles were later incorporated into the Declaration of Independence by Thomas Jefferson.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Philosophical Foundations of the American Revolution

More questions from this topic