Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardProgressive Era Reforms and Influences

Source: Gifford Pinchot, *The Fight for Conservation*, 1910

"The first principle of conservation is development, the use of the natural resources now existing on this continent for the benefit of the people who live here now. There may be just as much waste in neglecting the development and use of certain natural resources as there is in their destruction... The second principle is the prevention of waste... Conservation stands or falls on the question of whether or not it is reasonable to expect that the men of our time will be as wise and as public-spirited as those who went before them."

The philosophy outlined in the excerpt contributed to debates during the Progressive Era primarily by doing which of the following?

  1. Exposing a growing ideological division within the environmental movement between advocates of planned resource management and proponents of complete wilderness preservation.Answer
  2. B
    Promoting a return to Gilded Age laissez-faire policies that allowed private timber and mining corporations unregulated access to federal lands.
  3. C
    Fulfilling the Populist Party's demand that the federal government nationalize all natural resources and agricultural land.
  4. D
    Attempting to reverse the environmental transformations and infrastructure expansions initiated by the nineteenth-century Market Revolution.

Answer

Exposing a growing ideological division within the environmental movement between advocates of planned resource management and proponents of complete wilderness preservation.
The correct answer describes the primary debate within the Progressive-era environmental movement. Gifford Pinchot's conservation philosophy focused on the efficient, scientifically managed development of natural resources to prevent waste and benefit the public interest. This utilitarian approach stood in sharp contrast to the preservationist philosophy championed by John Muir and the Sierra Club, who advocated for protecting nature in its pristine state, free from human development or economic exploitation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus source and context.
The source is Gifford Pinchot writing in 1910, representing the utilitarian conservation perspective of the Progressive Era.
Identifying the author and his viewpoint helps place the document in the correct historical debate.
2
Identify the core argument of the excerpt.
Pinchot argues that conservation requires 'development' and the active use of resources for the benefit of current populations, rather than leaving them unused.
Determining the core argument allows for comparison with contemporary historical movements and ideologies.
3
Evaluate the options against the historical debate.
Pinchot's view represents conservation (controlled use), which contrasted sharply with John Muir's preservationism (non-use), reflecting the main division in environmental politics of the era.
Connecting the stimulus to the correct historical tension yields the correct answer.

Key Concept

Progressive Era Environmental Politics (Conservation vs. Preservation)
Rate this question

Topics

Progressive Era Reforms and Influences

More questions from this topic