Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardThe Constitutional Convention and Ratification Debates

Patrick Henry, speech at the Virginia Ratifying Convention, 1788:

"Here is a resolution as revolutionary as the half-way house of the English revolution. The question turns on that poor little thing—the expression, 'We, the people,' instead of 'We, the states,' of America. . . . States are the characteristics and the soul of a confederation. If the states be not the agents of this compact, it must be one great, consolidated, national government, of the people of all the states."

Which of the following arguments did proponents of the Constitution most commonly use to address the criticism expressed by Henry in the excerpt?

  1. They asserted that the new government would be a compound republic, combining both national and federal features to preserve state sovereignty.Answer
  2. B
    They claimed that the Articles of Confederation had already established a consolidated national government, rendering Henry’s fears moot.
  3. C
    They argued that the direct election of the president by the national electorate would ensure the executive remained accountable to the states.
  4. D
    They advocated for a strict constructionist interpretation of federal powers to guarantee that states remained the sole source of political authority.

Answer

The correct answer states that proponents asserted the new government would be a compound republic, combining both national and federal features to preserve state sovereignty.
The correct option is correct because during the ratification debates, Federalists (most notably James Madison in Federalist No. 39) defended the Constitution against charges of consolidation by arguing that it created a novel 'compound' government. This system blended national elements (deriving power directly from the people) with federal elements (preserving the distinct existence and authority of the states), thereby maintaining a balance of shared sovereignty.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the primary source excerpt to identify the speaker's main concern.
Patrick Henry is concerned that the phrase 'We, the people' instead of 'We, the states' signals the creation of a 'consolidated' national government that will destroy state sovereignty.
This establishes the historical context of the debate between Anti-Federalists (who favored state sovereignty) and Federalists.
2
Evaluate the Federalist response to this specific Anti-Federalist concern.
In Federalist No. 39, James Madison argued that the Constitution established a 'compound' system: it was national in some aspects (like representation in the House) but federal in others (like equal representation in the Senate and ratification by state conventions).
This connects Henry's critique directly to the intellectual defense of the Constitution's structure.
3
Compare this defense to the provided options to identify the correct historical argument.
The option describing the proposed government as a compound republic with shared sovereignty is the correct match.
It accurately reflects the Federalist rebuttal to accusations of complete national consolidation.

Key Concept

The Federalist and Anti-Federalist debates over federalism and state sovereignty during ratification
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

The Constitutional Convention and Ratification Debates

More questions from this topic