Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumTypes of Representative Democracy

In the wake of a major corporate data breach that exposed the personal information of millions of citizens, a small group of tech executives and high-ranking security officials meet privately with federal regulators to draft new cybersecurity standards. Critics argue that the resulting regulations protect the interests of major technology firms rather than safeguarding consumer privacy.

Which of the following models of representative democracy is best illustrated by this scenario?

  1. A
    Participatory democracy, because individual citizens can directly vote on and veto the proposed standards before they take effect.
  2. B
    Pluralist democracy, because the scenario features multiple competing interests collaborating to find a compromise that benefits the public.
  3. Elite democracy, because a small group of wealthy and powerful industry leaders holds the power to shape regulatory policy.Answer
  4. D
    Popular sovereignty, because the federal officials drafting the regulations represent the authority and consent of the entire electorate.

Answer

Elite democracy, because a small group of wealthy and powerful industry leaders holds the power to shape regulatory policy.
The correct answer is elite democracy. In this model, a small, select group of individuals—often defined by wealth, social status, or corporate position—exercises disproportionate influence over government decisions. The scenario describes a private meeting of tech executives and regulators that results in policies favoring major corporations, illustrating the elite theory of democracy.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the key actors and their access to policymaking power in the scenario.
The actors are tech executives (economic elite) and federal regulators meeting privately, while critics argue the rules favor major firms over the public.
This identifies which model of representative democracy best fits the centralized, top-down nature of the policymaking process described.
2
Compare the scenario's dynamics to the definitions of the models of representative democracy.
The participatory model requires broad public involvement, and the pluralist model requires competing interest groups. The elite model is defined by a small, wealthy, and powerful subset of society driving policy, which aligns with the tech executives' private meeting and influence.
This leads to the identification of the correct model by eliminating options that describe broad-based or group-based competition.

Key Concept

Models of Representative Democracy
Rate this question

Topics

Types of Representative Democracy

More questions from this topic