Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardDebates about the Environment after 1900

"The miracle seeds of the Green Revolution were supposed to banish hunger from the Third World. But in Punjab, where the new seeds were first introduced in India, the result has been ecological devastation and social unrest. Soils have been depleted of nutrients; the water table has plummeted because of the intensive irrigation required; and farmers have been driven into deep debt to pay for expensive chemical inputs. Far from being a triumph of ecological harmony, this model of development has replaced diverse, resilient local food systems with monocultures that are vulnerable to pests and dependent on external, fossil-fuel-based technologies."

���Vandana Shiva, Indian environmentalist and social activist, The Violence of the Green Revolution, 1991

Which of the following developments in the late twentieth century most directly contributed to the debates described in the passage?

  1. A
    The transition of direct colonial rule in the Global South to administration by international agricultural consortia.
  2. B
    The complete homogenization of global cultures, which eliminated all localized traditional farming techniques.
  3. The growing global debates over the environmental and social costs of industrial agricultural practices.Answer
  4. D
    The emergence of the Green Revolution as an eco-friendly movement aimed at promoting biodiversity and organic farming.

Answer

The correct answer states that the debates over the Green Revolution reflect the growing global discussions surrounding the environmental and social costs of industrial agricultural practices.
The correct answer is correct because the passage by Vandana Shiva critiques the ecological and social impacts of the Green Revolution in India, highlighting issues like soil degradation, depletion of water resources, and economic strain on local farmers. This directly illustrates the late-twentieth-century debates over the environmental and social consequences of industrial agricultural models that spread globally after 1900.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus passage to identify the author's primary argument and concerns.
The author (Vandana Shiva) argues that the Green Revolution in Punjab led to ecological problems, such as nutrient-depleted soils and dropping water tables, as well as social issues like farmer debt and monoculture vulnerability.
Understanding the specific critiques raised in the source is essential for contextualizing it within broader historical trends.
2
Connect the author's concerns to late-twentieth-century environmental developments.
The critiques highlight the post-1900 debates over the environment, specifically the tension between using industrial technologies to maximize food production and the ecological damage caused by those high-input agricultural methods.
This step aligns the specific historical source with the target AP World History learning objective regarding post-1900 environmental debates.
3
Evaluate the options to identify the development that accurately contextalizes the passage without historical inaccuracies.
The option focusing on global debates over the environmental and social costs of industrial agriculture matches the historical context. The other options introduce common misconceptions, such as conflating the Green Revolution with environmentalism, assuming complete cultural homogenization, or confusing economic influence with direct colonization.
This confirms the correct choice by systematically eliminating distractors based on established historical evidence.

Key Concept

Debates about the environmental and social impacts of the Green Revolution and industrial agriculture after 1900.
Rate this question

Topics

Debates about the Environment after 1900

More questions from this topic