Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumRise of Modern Nationalism and Nation-State Unification

Source: Ottoman Sultan Abdülmecid I, Imperial Edict of Gülhane (Tanzimat Edict), 1839.

"We deem it fit in the presence of all to state that the institutions of our Empire must be reformed. These institutions relate principally to three points: first, the guarantees which will ensure our subjects perfect security for their lives, their honor, and their property; second, a regular method of levying and collecting taxes; third, an equally regular method for the recruiting of the army and the duration of military service. Indeed, without these, there can be no strength, no wealth, no happiness, no peace for a state... From now on, the tax will be determined according to the fortune and capacity of each... All subjects of our Empire, of whatever religion or sect they may be, shall enjoy these concessions without exception."

The reform program outlined in the passage was most directly a response to which of the following nineteenth-century developments?

  1. The spread of nationalist ideologies that threatened the political cohesion of multiethnic empiresAnswer
  2. B
    The Ottoman state's attempt to restore the traditional devshirme system of military recruitment
  3. C
    The integration of Social Darwinist principles to justify Ottoman imperial expansion
  4. D
    The imposition of direct European colonial administration over the core Ottoman provinces

Answer

The spread of nationalist ideologies that threatened the political cohesion of multiethnic empires
The correct answer is correct because the Edict of Gülhane marked the beginning of the Tanzimat ('Reordering') era. The core goal of these reforms was 'Ottomanism'—a policy of promoting a unified civic identity by granting equal legal rights to all subjects, regardless of religion, in order to combat the growing nationalist movements and separatist tendencies among the empire's non-Muslim communities.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the Edict of Gülhane's provisions.
The Edict promises security of life, honor, and property, fair taxation, and military conscription for all subjects, regardless of religion or sect.
This identifies that the state is attempting to offer equal citizenship rights to non-Muslims as well as Muslims.
2
Assess the historical context of the Ottoman Empire in 1839.
The empire faced intense decentralization and nationalist uprisings, notably the Greek War of Independence (which succeeded in 1832) and ongoing unrest in the Balkan provinces.
This links the government's attempt to create a shared identity ('Ottomanism') with the external and internal threat of ethnic nationalism.
3
Evaluate the choices to determine the primary catalyst for these reforms.
The threat of minority nationalism separating from the empire aligns with the option addressing nationalist ideologies in multiethnic states.
This establishes the causal connection between the rise of modern nationalism and the Ottoman state's defensive modernization.

Key Concept

Rise of Modern Nationalism and Nation-State Unification
Rate this question

Topics

Rise of Modern Nationalism and Nation-State Unification

More questions from this topic