Question

Difficulty: HardPolitical Fragmentation and Rise of Islamic States

"The political fragmentation of the Abbasid Caliphate after the ninth century did not signal a cultural or intellectual retreat for Islamic society. Instead, the decentralization of authority led to the emergence of regional courts—such as those of the Samanids, Seljuks, and Mamluks—that actively competed for prestige. To legitimize their newly established regimes, these regional rulers established networks of colleges (*madrasas*) and generously patronized scientists, poets, and philosophers. Consequently, the dissemination of scientific and philosophical knowledge intensified, even as the political unity of the caliphate crumbled."
—Adapted from a modern historical study of medieval Islamic institutions

Which of the following developments in the period circa 1200 to 1450 best supports the author's argument in the passage?

  1. A
    The widespread decline of mathematical and philosophical scholarship following the political fragmentation of the caliphate.
  2. The continued flourishing of scientific and medical research in regional capitals such as Cairo and Delhi.Answer
  3. C
    The stagnation of architectural and cultural achievements as regional rulers prioritized military spending.
  4. D
    The collapse of educational networks and trade routes, which isolated scholars from the wider Afro-Eurasian world.

Answer

The correct answer is the option stating that scientific and medical research continued to flourish in regional capitals such as Cairo and Delhi.
The correct option is supported by the historical reality that regional Islamic states—such as the Mamluk Sultanate in Cairo and the Delhi Sultanate in India—became major political and cultural centers that sponsored schools, hospitals, and libraries, demonstrating that political fragmentation did not lead to intellectual or cultural decline.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the provided stimulus to identify the author's main argument.
The author argues that the political fragmentation of the Abbasid Caliphate did not lead to cultural or intellectual decline; instead, regional courts competed for legitimacy by patronizing scholars and building educational institutions.
Understanding the core argument is necessary to evaluate which historical development supports it.
2
Evaluate the historical developments in Dar al-Islam between 1200 and 1450 relative to the argument.
During this period, new regional states like the Mamluk Sultanate in Egypt and the Delhi Sultanate in India arose. These states built major centers of learning and continued to advance science, astronomy, and medicine.
This step connects the theoretical argument in the text to concrete historical evidence from the specified time period.
3
Determine which option aligns with the evidence of regional intellectual vitality.
The statement regarding the continued flourishing of scientific and medical research in Cairo and Delhi directly supports the author's claim that intellectual activity persisted and expanded despite political division.
This identifies the correct choice based on historical evidence and the stimulus argument.

Key Concept

Political Fragmentation and Rise of Islamic States
Rate this question