Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardInternal and External Challenges to State Power

The Parliament, having assembled this morning, resolved to demand the release of Broussel, who had been arrested by the court. The queen regent refused, declaring that the royal authority must be maintained at all costs. Immediately, the people of Paris took up arms, chains were stretched across the streets, and barricades were erected near the Palais-Royal. The citizens, led by members of the nobility who oppose the regency, refuse to submit to the demands of Cardinal Mazarin. They demand the restoration of their ancient privileges and an end to the extraordinary taxes levied to fund foreign wars. If the court does not yield, we face a total breakdown of order in the kingdom.

— Adapted from the memoirs of Cardinal de Retz, a French churchman and noble active in the Fronde rebellions, describing events in Paris, 1648

The political instability described in the passage was most directly a reaction to which of the following developments in Europe between 1450 and 1750?

  1. A
    The shift toward free-market capitalism and the dismantling of mercantilist economic policies by the monarchy.
  2. B
    The implementation of the devshirme system to replace hereditary noble advisors with enslaved bureaucrats.
  3. The consolidation of absolute royal power and state centralization at the expense of traditional elites.Answer
  4. D
    The return to feudal decentralized governance to protect borders from external threats.

Answer

The consolidation of absolute royal power and state centralization at the expense of traditional elites.
The correct answer is correct because the Fronde (1648–1653) was a series of civil wars in France that represented a major internal challenge to royal authority. It was caused by the efforts of the French crown, particularly under Cardinals Richelieu and Mazarin, to centralize state administration, increase taxation, and diminish the traditional political privileges of the nobility and the parlements.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the stimulus to identify the core conflict.
The passage describes an armed uprising in Paris where nobles and parliamentary members are resisting the Queen Regent and Cardinal Mazarin due to concerns over 'royal authority' and 'extraordinary taxes.'
This establishes that the conflict is an internal challenge to French state authority by traditional elites.
2
Contextualize the conflict within early modern European state development (1450–1750).
During this era, European monarchs were actively building absolute power, centralizing administrative structures, and reducing the influence of regional nobility and local legislative bodies.
This links the specific events of the Fronde (1648) to the broader thematic objective of challenges to state power.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the trend that directly prompted this resistance.
The resistance was a response to centralized monarchical overreach. Thus, the consolidation of absolute royal power at the expense of traditional elites is the correct cause.
This step validates the correct answer while eliminating distractors that rely on geographical, chronological, or structural errors.

Key Concept

Internal challenges to state power in the early modern era
Rate this question

Topics

Internal and External Challenges to State Power

More questions from this topic