Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardThe Role of the Police

In the Australian legal system, the police operate under a specific set of rules to ensure they serve the community fairly. Which of the following accurately describes the relationship between the police, the law, and the government in Australia?

  1. A
    The police are a branch of the government that has the power to create temporary laws to maintain order during emergencies.
  2. The police are independent of the government, must follow the law themselves, and are responsible for enforcing laws rather than making them.Answer
  3. C
    The police have the authority to decide if a person is guilty of a crime and can determine the length of a prison sentence for minor offences.

Answer

The police are independent of the government, must follow the law themselves, and are responsible for enforcing laws rather than making them.
The correct answer is correct because it identifies the three core pillars of the police's role: they are independent of political control, they are subject to the same laws as everyone else, and their function is limited to law enforcement rather than legislation or sentencing.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the relationship between the police and the government.
The police are an independent body and are not under the direct control of the government of the day.
Independence ensures that the law is applied fairly to everyone, including government officials.
2
Determine the legislative limits of the police.
Police do not have the power to make laws.
Under the Australian system, the power to make laws belongs to the Parliament (the legislative branch).
3
Identify the judicial limits of the police.
Police cannot decide if a person is guilty or what their punishment should be.
These roles belong to the courts and judges to ensure a fair trial and separation of powers.
4
Combine these principles to identify the correct description.
The police enforce laws made by Parliament and leave the decision of guilt and punishment to the courts, all while remaining independent of the government.
This matches the legal framework of the Australian justice system.

Key Concept

The Independence and Limited Authority of the Police

Hints

1
Think about the 'Separation of Powers'. Does the person who catches a suspect also get to decide the punishment?
2
Consider who makes the laws in Australia. Is it the police officers on the street or the representatives in Parliament?

Practice More

Review the roles of the three levels of government to see how they differ from the roles of the police and courts.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

The Role of the Police

More questions from this topic