Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardTolerance of Differing Opinions

A local volunteer organization is planning its annual charity gala. During a planning meeting, one member proposes that the group should immediately stop supporting its traditional local healthcare partner and instead redirect all funds to a controversial international political campaign. Most other volunteers find this suggestion disrespectful to the organization's history and deeply unpopular. In accordance with the Australian value of tolerance for differing opinions, what is the correct way for the members of the organization to handle this situation?

  1. They should allow the member to express their suggestion and engage in a peaceful discussion about the proposal, even if they strongly disagree with it.Answer
  2. B
    They should prevent the member from speaking about the topic to protect the other volunteers from feeling offended and to maintain the harmony of the group.
  3. C
    They should allow the member to speak but are justified in using verbal intimidation and personal insults to ensure the individual knows their opinion is not welcome.

Answer

The members should allow the individual to express their suggestion and engage in a peaceful discussion, respecting their right to hold an unpopular opinion.
The correct answer reflects the Australian value that individuals must be allowed to express their views peacefully. In a democratic society like Australia, tolerance means accepting that others have the right to different perspectives, even if those perspectives challenge traditions or are deeply unpopular with the majority. The correct response to such views is peaceful debate or discussion, not censorship.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the core conflict in the scenario.
A member has proposed an extremely unpopular and potentially offensive change to a group's traditional activities.
Understanding the nature of the disagreement is necessary to apply the correct value.
2
Apply the Australian value of 'Tolerance of Differing Opinions'.
Tolerance means that even if a view is deeply unpopular or offensive to the majority, the individual has the right to express it peacefully.
Australian society is built on the principle that everyone has the right to their own opinion and can express it within the law.
3
Evaluate the appropriate method of disagreement.
Disagreement must be handled through peaceful debate, voting, or discussion, rather than through silencing, intimidation, or abuse.
Mutual respect requires that we allow others to have their say, even if we do not agree with their perspective.
4
Select the option that matches this application.
The option advocating for peaceful discussion despite strong disagreement is the correct choice.
It aligns with both the right to speak and the requirement for peaceful interaction.

Key Concept

In Australia, people are free to hold and express their own opinions, even if those opinions are unpopular or disagree with the majority, as long as they are expressed peacefully and within the law.

Hints

1
Think about whether a majority has the right to stop a minority from speaking in Australia.
2
Consider the difference between 'tolerating' a view and 'agreeing' with it. Does tolerance require you to be quiet or allow others to be quiet?
3
Australian values state that we should respect the right of others to have their say, even if we find what they say to be offensive or unpopular.

Practice More

Review the section on 'Mutual Respect and Tolerance' in the official citizenship study guide to understand the boundaries between free speech and illegal behavior.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Tolerance of Differing Opinions

More questions from this topic