Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardStopping Distance Components

A fleet safety director is reviewing telematics data comparing two commercial trucks of equal gross weight traveling at 55 mph55\text{ mph} (80.7 ft/s80.7\text{ ft/s}) on dry, level pavement. Truck 1 uses a standard hydraulic braking system, while Truck 2 uses an S-cam air brake system. Both drivers have a standard perception time of 1.75 seconds1.75\text{ seconds} (142 feet142\text{ feet}) and a reaction time of 0.75 seconds0.75\text{ seconds} (61 feet61\text{ feet}). Once the brake linings contact the drums, both vehicles require a physical braking distance of 216 feet216\text{ feet}. Assuming the air brake system adds an air brake lag of 0.5 seconds0.5\text{ seconds} before mechanical braking begins, which statement correctly quantifies the difference in total stopping distance between Truck 2 and Truck 1, and identifies the mechanical reason for this difference?

  1. A
    Both vehicles have an identical total stopping distance of 419 feet419\text{ feet} because air brake lag only occurs during emergency breakaway events and does not add distance during standard service stops.
  2. Truck 2 requires approximately 40 feet40\text{ feet} more stopping distance (459 feet459\text{ feet} vs. 419 feet419\text{ feet}) because air brakes include a fourth component—brake lag distance—during which air flows through the lines before the friction linings contact the drums.Answer
  3. C
    Truck 2 requires approximately 142 feet142\text{ feet} more stopping distance (419 feet419\text{ feet} vs. 277 feet277\text{ feet}) because hydraulic systems completely eliminate human perception distance, leaving only reaction and braking distances.
  4. D
    Truck 2 requires approximately 81 feet81\text{ feet} more stopping distance because commercial air brake systems require doubling the driver's reaction time from 0.75 seconds0.75\text{ seconds} to 1.75 seconds1.75\text{ seconds} to build reservoir pressure.

Answer

Truck 2 requires approximately 40 feet40\text{ feet} more stopping distance (459 feet459\text{ feet} vs. 419 feet419\text{ feet}) because air brakes include a fourth component—brake lag distance—during which air flows through the lines before the friction linings contact the drums.
Total stopping distance for hydraulic brake commercial vehicles comprises three components: perception distance, reaction distance, and braking distance (142 ft+61 ft+216 ft=419 feet142\text{ ft} + 61\text{ ft} + 216\text{ ft} = 419\text{ feet}). In contrast, air brake vehicles require four components: perception distance, reaction distance, brake lag distance, and braking distance. At 55 mph55\text{ mph} (80.7 ft/s80.7\text{ ft/s}), a 0.5 second0.5\text{ second} air lag adds approximately 40 feet40\text{ feet} (142 ft+61 ft+40 ft+216 ft=459 feet142\text{ ft} + 61\text{ ft} + 40\text{ ft} + 216\text{ ft} = 459\text{ feet}), requiring the air-braked vehicle to travel 40 feet40\text{ feet} farther before coming to a complete stop.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Calculate the total stopping distance components for Truck 1 (hydraulic brakes).
Total Stopping Distance = Perception Distance (142 ft142\text{ ft}) + Reaction Distance (61 ft61\text{ ft}) + Braking Distance (216 ft216\text{ ft}) = 419 feet419\text{ feet}.
Hydraulic brake stopping distance consists of three components because hydraulic fluid is incompressible and transmits force virtually instantaneously.
2
Calculate the additional brake lag distance and total stopping distance for Truck 2 (air brakes).
Brake Lag Distance = 80.7 ft/s×0.5 s≈40.35 feet80.7\text{ ft/s} \times 0.5\text{ s} \approx 40.35\text{ feet} (approx. 40 ft40\text{ ft}). Total Stopping Distance = 142 ft+61 ft+40 ft+216 ft=459 feet142\text{ ft} + 61\text{ ft} + 40\text{ ft} + 216\text{ ft} = 459\text{ feet}.
Air brakes introduce a fourth physical component—air brake lag (about 0.5 seconds0.5\text{ seconds})—due to the time required for compressed air to travel through valves and lines to push out the brake pushrods.
3
Determine the difference in stopping distance between the two braking systems.
Difference = 459 ft−419 ft=40 feet459\text{ ft} - 419\text{ ft} = 40\text{ feet}.
The extra distance is entirely accounted for by the air brake lag phase before mechanical braking friction begins.

Key Concept

Air Brake Stopping Distance vs. Hydraulic Stopping Distance Components
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Stopping Distance Components

More questions from this topic