Question

Difficulty: MediumStrengthening Arguments

A commercial fruit exporter plans to introduce low-concentration ozone gas injection into its long-distance refrigerated shipping containers to prevent mold decay in bananas during transit. Skeptics argue that ozone exposure can accelerate fruit ripening and softening by triggering ethylene production. The exporter claims that using ozone gas will successfully extend the saleable shelf life of the fruit upon arrival at distant ports without causing premature softening. Which of the following, if true, provides the strongest support for the fruit exporter's claim?

  1. A
    Bananas exposed to low-concentration ozone gas produce significantly higher baseline levels of ethylene than bananas kept in standard refrigerated air.
  2. At low concentrations, ozone gas rapidly oxidizes and neutralizes ambient ethylene in enclosed spaces before the ethylene can bind to fruit ripening receptors.Answer
  3. C
    Retail consumers in major export markets increasingly report a willingness to pay premium prices for fruit preserved without synthetic chemical fungicides.
  4. D
    Mold decay currently accounts for over forty percent of total fruit losses reported during transoceanic shipping operations.
  5. E
    Refrigerated containers equipped with ozone delivery systems require lower electrical power to maintain target internal temperatures.

Answer

The statement showing that ozone gas neutralizes ambient ethylene before it can bind to fruit receptors provides the strongest support for the exporter's claim.
The correct answer provides a chemical mechanism that directly defends the argument against the main objection. The critics argue that ozone causes softening by triggering ethylene. If low concentrations of ozone actually neutralize ambient ethylene before it can affect the fruit, the ozone removes the very agent responsible for premature ripening while still treating mold. This strongly supports the exporter's conclusion.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the core argument and main vulnerability
The exporter claims ozone will extend shelf life without premature softening. The main objection is that ozone triggers ethylene production, causing softening.
To strengthen the argument, an option must resolve the vulnerability by showing why ozone will not lead to ethylene-induced softening.
2
Evaluate the impact of the correct mechanism
If ozone oxidizes and neutralizes ethylene gas, it removes the trigger for premature ripening and softening.
This directly neutralizes the skeptics' counterargument and confirms that mold protection will occur without the negative side effect.

Key Concept

Strengthening Arguments
Rate this question