Question

Difficulty: HardOverlapping Sets and Venn Diagrams

A financial consulting firm audited 500500 corporate investment portfolios for exposure to three alternative asset classes: Private Equity (PP), Venture Capital (VV), and Infrastructure (II). Every audited portfolio contained at least one of the three asset classes.

The audit revealed the following:
- Exactly 270270 portfolios contained Private Equity.
- Exactly 250250 portfolios contained Venture Capital.
- Exactly 220220 portfolios contained Infrastructure.
- The ratio of the number of portfolios containing both Private Equity and Venture Capital to those containing both Venture Capital and Infrastructure to those containing both Private Equity and Infrastructure was 11:9:1011 : 9 : 10, respectively.
- The number of portfolios containing all three asset classes was 6060.

How many portfolios contained exactly two of the three asset classes?

Answer: 120 portfolios

Answer

The total number of portfolios containing exactly two of the three asset classes is 120.
Using the 3-set inclusion-exclusion formula, we establish that 500=270+250+220(11k+9k+10k)+60500 = 270 + 250 + 220 - (11k + 9k + 10k) + 60, which simplifies to 30k=30030k = 300, so k=10k = 10. The sum of the pairwise intersections is 110+90+100=300110 + 90 + 100 = 300. Since each pairwise intersection includes the 60 portfolios that contain all three asset classes, the number of portfolios containing exactly two asset classes is (11060)+(9060)+(10060)=50+30+40=120(110-60) + (90-60) + (100-60) = 50 + 30 + 40 = 120.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Set up the 3-Set Inclusion-Exclusion Principle equation
Total=P+V+I(PV+VI+PI)+PVI\text{Total} = |P| + |V| + |I| - (|P \cap V| + |V \cap I| + |P \cap I|) + |P \cap V \cap I|
This formula accounts for all region overlaps without double-counting or triple-counting.
2
Define variables using the given ratio for pairwise intersections
PV=11k|P \cap V| = 11k, VI=9k|V \cap I| = 9k, and PI=10k|P \cap I| = 10k
Expressing the pairwise intersection sizes with a common ratio constant kk allows us to substitute them into a single-variable linear equation.
3
Substitute the known numerical values and solve for kk
500=270+250+220(11k+9k+10k)+60    500=80030k    k=10500 = 270 + 250 + 220 - (11k + 9k + 10k) + 60 \implies 500 = 800 - 30k \implies k = 10
Using algebraic simplification to solve for kk gives the scaling factor for the pairwise intersections.
4
Calculate the actual sizes of the pairwise intersections
PV=110|P \cap V| = 110, VI=90|V \cap I| = 90, and PI=100|P \cap I| = 100; Sum of pairwise intersections = 300300
Multiplying each ratio term by k=10k=10 gives the exact count of portfolios containing at least the respective pairs.
5
Calculate portfolios containing exactly two asset classes
(11060)+(9060)+(10060)=50+30+40=120(110 - 60) + (90 - 60) + (100 - 60) = 50 + 30 + 40 = 120
The triple intersection (6060) must be subtracted from each pairwise overlap to isolate the regions corresponding to portfolios holding exactly two asset classes.

Key Concept

Three-Set Overlapping Venn Diagrams and Inclusion-Exclusion Principle
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question