Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardErrors of Composition and Division

Consider the following argument regarding financial market stability:

'In a stress test of national financial reserves, every individual commercial bank evaluated maintained sufficient liquid assets to independently settle all immediate obligation demands under isolated distress. Therefore, the national commercial banking network as a whole is guaranteed to withstand a simultaneous, market-wide liquidity crisis without systemic insolvency.'

True or False: The argument commits an error of composition by inferring that a property held by each individual component of a system under isolated conditions necessarily applies to the entire system operating under aggregate conditions.

Answer: Answer

Answer

True. The statement accurately identifies that the argument commits an error of composition by improperly transferring a property of individual entities to the aggregate network.
The statement is True because the argument erroneously projects the solvency and liquidity traits of individual banks operating in isolation onto the entire banking network operating during a systemic crisis, exemplifying the fallacy of composition.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the logical structure of the argument.
Premise: Every single commercial bank independently possesses sufficient liquidity to withstand an isolated distress event. Conclusion: The banking network as a whole is guaranteed to withstand a simultaneous, market-wide liquidity crisis.
Analyzing the scope of the premise versus the conclusion reveals structural shifts between parts and the whole.
2
Examine the shift in context from individual parts to the combined whole.
The reasoning assumes that because a condition holds true for each individual bank operating in isolation, it must also hold true for all banks operating collectively during a simultaneous, systemic crisis.
Systemic network interactions and feedback loops frequently invalidate simple aggregation of individual traits.
3
Match the logical error to standard error taxonomies.
The flaw of assuming that what applies to each individual part of a system necessarily applies to the whole system is an Error of Composition.
This confirms that the evaluation statement is True.

Key Concept

Error of Composition
Rate this question

Topics

Errors of Composition and Division

More questions from this topic