Question

Difficulty: MediumFunctional Role of Specific Details

Passage: Planetary scientists long assumed that small, distant bodies in the Kuiper Belt would be geologically inert worlds preserved in deep-freeze since the solar system's formation. However, data returned by the New Horizons probe revealed surprising resurfacing activity on Pluto, particularly within Sputnik Planitia, a vast basin filled with nitrogen-rich ice. To account for the absence of impact craters across this basin, researchers proposed a thermal convection model driven by Pluto's modest internal radiogenic heat. In this model, solid nitrogen—which becomes soft and ductile even at temperatures of 40 Kelvin—rises in warm convective plumes, spreads horizontally at the surface, and sinks along cooler margins.

To support this hypothesis, planetary geologists point to the prominent networks of polygonal troughs dividing Sputnik Planitia's ice sheets into cells several tens of kilometers wide. Computer simulations demonstrate that the spatial wavelength of these polygons closely matches the predicted aspect ratio of thermal convection cells operating within an ice layer several kilometers thick. Crucially, the presence of dark material concentrated exclusively within the bounding troughs, rather than across the cell interiors, indicates that surface ice is continuously conveyed toward the margins before descending into the subsurface. Were the surface shaped primarily by wind erosion or sublimation-driven thermal fracturing, the spatial pattern of impurities would be randomly distributed across the plains. Thus, the specific arrangement of these boundary deposits serves to validate internal thermal convection as the primary driver of Pluto's youthful surface dynamics.

Which of the following best describes the primary function of the author's reference to 'the presence of dark material concentrated exclusively within the bounding troughs' in the second paragraph?

  1. It provides empirical evidence supporting the convection hypothesis over alternative explanations for the surface features.Answer
  2. B
    It summarizes the primary heat-generation mechanism operating within Pluto's interior core.
  3. C
    It proves conclusively that wind erosion and sublimation play no role in shaping planetary ice surfaces.
  4. D
    It illustrates a phenomenon that traditional models of Kuiper Belt objects had predicted prior to the New Horizons mission.
  5. E
    It establishes that the nitrogen ice layer in Sputnik Planitia is significantly thicker than previously estimated.

Answer

The statement's primary function is to provide empirical evidence supporting the internal thermal convection hypothesis over competing explanations (such as wind erosion or sublimation-driven thermal fracturing) for the observed surface features.
The reference to the concentration of dark material within bounding troughs acts as crucial empirical evidence for convective lateral motion. The author explicitly contrasts this specific non-random pattern with what would be expected under alternative mechanisms (wind erosion or thermal fracturing), thereby using the detail to validate the internal thermal convection model.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the targeted detail in the text and review its immediate context.
The reference appears in the second paragraph, following the introduction of the convection hypothesis and preceding a contrast with wind erosion and sublimation-driven fracturing.
Understanding what precedes and follows a detail reveals why the author introduced it.
2
Analyze the logical role of the sentence containing the detail.
The author notes that dark material concentrated in troughs shows ice being conveyed to margins. The next sentence explicitly states that wind erosion or sublimation would instead yield randomly distributed impurities.
The contrast shows that the specific spatial distribution rules out competing mechanisms and supports thermal convection.
3
Select the choice that correctly states this rhetorical purpose.
The option stating that the detail provides empirical evidence supporting the convection hypothesis over alternative explanations correctly captures this function.
It matches the author's explicit conclusion that the arrangement of deposits serves to validate internal thermal convection.

Key Concept

Functional Role of Specific Details
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question