Question

Difficulty: MediumContextual Vocabulary and Pronoun Reference

In his 1840 treatise on organic chemistry applied to agriculture, Justus von Liebig posited that plant growth is limited not by the abundance of organic humus in the soil, but by the relative scarcity of specific inorganic minerals. To address soil degradation, Liebig advocated the application of artificial mineral fertilizers to replace depleted salts. However, when early field trials of his synthesized manures yielded disappointing results, contemporary agronomists attributed the failure to the insolubility of the chemical preparations, which prevented crop roots from absorbing the essential nutrients. In responding to these critiques, Liebig argued that the apparent failure stemmed not from chemical defects in the fertilizers themselves, but rather from the improper cultivation practices of farmers who neglected soil aeration. He asserted that without adequate tillage, the mineral salts could not react effectively with soil moisture, rendering them inert. This oversight, Liebig maintained, perpetuated the very exhaustion that his mineral formulation was engineered to reverse.

In the passage, the phrase "This oversight" in the final sentence refers to which of the following?

  1. A
    The contention among contemporary agronomists that synthesized manures suffered from chemical defects
  2. The failure of farmers to perform adequate tillage and ensure proper soil aerationAnswer
  3. C
    The inherent insolubility of the artificial mineral salts when introduced into soil moisture
  4. D
    The widespread application of artificial fertilizers to farmland suffering from mineral depletion
  5. E
    The assumption that organic humus plays no role in limiting agricultural plant growth

Answer

The phrase 'This oversight' refers to the failure of farmers to perform adequate tillage and ensure proper soil aeration.
In the penultimate sentence, Liebig explains that the failure of his fertilizer was caused by 'improper cultivation practices of farmers who neglected soil aeration' and notes that 'without adequate tillage, the mineral salts could not react effectively.' The demonstrative phrase 'This oversight' at the start of the final sentence directly refers to this failure of farmers to properly till the soil and aerate it.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the target phrase in the passage context
The phrase 'This oversight' appears at the beginning of the final sentence.
Demonstrative references ('this' + noun) refer back to a specific concept or action introduced in the immediately preceding text.
2
Analyze the immediate preceding sentence for potential noun antecedents
The preceding sentence states that 'without adequate tillage, the mineral salts could not react effectively with soil moisture, rendering them inert,' building on the point that farmers 'neglected soil aeration.'
An 'oversight' denotes an act of omission or failure to take proper care, matching the description of farmers neglecting aeration and failing to till adequately.
3
Evaluate the option choices against the identified antecedent
The choice describing the failure of farmers to perform adequate tillage and ensure proper soil aeration accurately encapsulates the antecedent.
This choice reflects Liebig's precise attribution of procedural neglect without introducing external or misattributed claims.

Key Concept

Contextual Pronoun and Demonstrative Reference
Rate this question