Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Premises and Evidence

To mitigate urban heat island effects, municipal planners in Oakhaven proposed planting deciduous trees along major commercial corridors. Critics argued that winter leaf drops would significantly increase sidewalk maintenance costs for local business owners. However, a comprehensive study of similar mid-sized cities revealed that commercial corridors with dense tree canopies consistently experience an eight percent boost in winter foot traffic, generating retail sales revenues that far exceed seasonal street sweeping expenses. Therefore, implementing the tree-planting initiative will yield a net financial gain for corridor merchants.

Which of the following best describes the function of the claim that commercial corridors with dense tree canopies consistently experience an eight percent boost in winter foot traffic?

  1. It provides factual evidence offered to support the author's ultimate conclusion that the initiative will be financially advantageous.Answer
  2. B
    It is introductory background information describing the general environmental context of urban heat island mitigation.
  3. C
    It is the main conclusion of the argument that all other claims are intended to establish.
  4. D
    It is an intermediate conclusion deduced directly from the critics' objection about maintenance expenses.
  5. E
    It represents a counterargument raised by opponents to demonstrate the potential drawbacks of the tree-planting proposal.

Answer

The statement functions as factual evidence supporting the main conclusion that the initiative will yield a net financial gain for merchants.
The statement about the eight percent boost in winter foot traffic provides explicit empirical evidence demonstrating how merchant revenues will rise. This evidence is used directly by the author to justify the final conclusion that the initiative will result in a net financial benefit.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main conclusion of the argument.
The final sentence contains the main conclusion: implementing the tree-planting initiative will yield a net financial gain for corridor merchants.
The conclusion indicator 'Therefore' introduces the author's primary claim.
2
Analyze the role of the target claim within the overall logical flow.
The target claim reports data from a study of similar cities showing an 8 percent boost in winter foot traffic.
This finding explains why additional retail revenues will outweigh maintenance costs, providing the essential premise that justifies the conclusion.
3
Evaluate the option choices to select the accurate structural description.
The correct description recognizes the claim as factual evidence supporting the primary conclusion.
The claim serves as a premise rather than background, a main conclusion, an intermediate conclusion, or a counterargument.

Key Concept

Identifying Premises and Structural Evidence
Rate this question