Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyIdentifying Unstated Assumptions

Consider the following argument: A regional art museum recently replaced all single-use plastic water bottles in its cafeteria with reusable glass bottles. Museum administrators claim that this policy will significantly reduce the cafeteria's overall carbon footprint over the coming year. Evaluate the following statement: The argument depends on the assumption that the energy consumed in manufacturing and repeatedly washing the reusable glass bottles does not produce greenhouse gas emissions that equal or exceed the emissions saved by eliminating the single-use plastic bottles.

Answer: Answer

Answer

True
The statement accurately expresses a necessary unstated assumption of the argument. If the emissions involved in creating and repeatedly cleaning the glass bottles were equal to or higher than those generated by single-use plastic bottles, switching to glass would fail to reduce the carbon footprint, undermining the administrators' claim.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Deconstruct the argument into its core premise and conclusion.
Premise: The museum replaced single-use plastic bottles with reusable glass bottles. Conclusion: The policy will significantly lower the cafeteria's carbon footprint.
Identifying the gap between the premise and conclusion reveals what must be assumed for the conclusion to be valid.
2
Apply the Negation Test to the statement.
Negated Statement: The energy consumed in producing and washing glass bottles DOES produce emissions equal to or greater than the emissions saved from eliminating plastic bottles.
If the logical negation of a statement invalidates the argument's conclusion, that statement is a necessary unstated assumption.
3
Evaluate the impact of the negated statement on the conclusion.
If glass bottle lifecycle emissions equal or exceed plastic bottle emissions, the conclusion that the carbon footprint will decrease is destroyed.
Because negating the statement breaks the argument, the statement is a required unstated assumption.

Key Concept

Identifying Unstated Assumptions via the Negation Test
Rate this question

Topics

Identifying Unstated Assumptions

More questions from this topic