Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Primary Purpose and Main Idea

Passage:

For over a century, economic historians attributed the prolonged sixteenth-century European inflation known as the Price Revolution primarily to the influx of silver from the Americas. According to this monetarist view, the surge in bullion increased the circulating money supply faster than real economic output, driving up commodity prices across the continent. However, recent quantitative reassessments have challenged this singular focus by demonstrating that price increases initiated decades before American silver arrived in substantial volumes. Demographic historians contend that population recovery following the Black Death created severe structural imbalances: demand for basic foodstuffs rapidly outpaced agricultural supply, while a surplus of labor depressed real wages. This demographic pressure, rather than monetary expansion alone, catalyzed early price increases. While American silver undoubtedly exacerbated inflation during its mid-century peak, it operated on an economy already strained by structural scarcity. Consequently, contemporary scholars view the Price Revolution not as a simple monetary phenomenon, but as a complex interplay between demographic recovery and monetary expansion, with demographic factors providing the initial impulse.

Statement: The primary purpose of the passage is to argue that demographic recovery was exclusively responsible for sixteenth-century European inflation.

Answer: Answer

Answer

The statement is False. The passage argues for a synthesis of demographic and monetary factors rather than claiming demographic recovery was exclusively responsible for the inflation.
The statement is false because the author explicitly refrains from attributing sixteenth-century inflation to a single exclusive cause. The passage outlines how demographic pressure acted as the initial impulse while American silver exacerbated the trend, concluding that the Price Revolution was a complex interplay of both monetary and demographic forces.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the scope and main thesis of the passage
The passage shifts from a traditional monetarist view (silver influx) to a multi-causal view combining demographic pressure as the initial catalyst and silver influx as an exacerbating factor.
Identifying the author's nuanced stance is necessary to evaluate statements about the primary purpose.
2
Compare the statement's claim against the passage's concluding synthesis
The statement uses the extreme word 'exclusively', whereas the text states the inflation was a 'complex interplay between demographic recovery and monetary expansion'.
Primary purpose statements must match the precise scope and tone of the author's central claim without exaggerating.
3
Determine the truth value of the statement
Because the statement overstates the author's position by claiming demographic factors were exclusively responsible, it is false.
An inaccurate characterization of the main idea renders the statement false.

Key Concept

Identifying Primary Purpose and Avoiding Exaggerated Scope Traps
Rate this question