Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardIdentifying Underlying Assumptions

Agricultural researchers recently introduced a specialized bio-inoculant containing the fungal strain *Glomus intraradices-X*, designed to bolster root absorption in wheat crops during dry spells. In controlled trials conducted across several arid testing plots, wheat fields treated with the bio-inoculant produced a 25 percent higher grain yield than untreated control plots during a severe seasonal drought. Based on these results, the researchers concluded that widespread adoption of *Glomus intraradices-X* in commercial wheat farming will effectively mitigate crop yield losses caused by future severe droughts.

Which of the following statements represent unstated assumptions upon which the researchers' argument depends? Select all that apply.

  1. The higher yield observed in the treated trial plots was not primarily attributable to unrecorded differences in baseline soil nutrient levels or irrigation between the treated and untreated plots.Answer
  2. Repeated application of *Glomus intraradices-X* over multiple planting seasons will not alter soil chemistry in a manner that eventually impairs wheat crop drought resilience.Answer
  3. C
    The bio-inoculant is significantly less expensive to manufacture and distribute than existing synthetic chemical fertilizers.
  4. D
    Wheat crops treated with the fungal strain will also exhibit enhanced resistance to common root pathogens under normal rainfall conditions.
  5. E
    Commercial wheat farmers currently affected by drought conditions have expressed strong interest in incorporating biological soil treatments into their management practices.

Answer

The argument depends on the assumptions that the trial's higher yield was not caused by baseline environmental discrepancies rather than the inoculant, and that repeated application will not cause soil degradation that undermines long-term drought resilience.
Both selected statements are necessary unstated assumptions required by the argument. The statement concerning baseline soil and water control ensures that the trial's yield increase was genuinely caused by the fungal treatment rather than confounding environmental variables. Applying the Negation Test demonstrates that if baseline differences caused the yield increase, the conclusion is invalidated. Similarly, the statement regarding long-term soil chemistry ensures that the treatment remains effective over time; if repeated application degrades soil health and reduces drought resilience, widespread adoption cannot successfully mitigate future drought losses.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main conclusion and underlying premise.
Conclusion: Widespread adoption of the bio-inoculant will effectively mitigate wheat yield losses from future severe droughts. Premise: In controlled trials, treated plots produced 25% higher yield than untreated control plots during a severe drought.
Isolating the premise-to-conclusion bridge exposes missing logical links required for the conclusion to hold.
2
Apply the Negation Test to candidate assumptions.
Negating the statement regarding baseline soil nutrient and irrigation differences reveals that if the trial's yield difference was actually caused by external environmental factors, the bio-inoculant's efficacy is unproven, collapsing the argument. Negating the statement about long-term soil chemistry changes shows that if repeated use degrades soil health, widespread adoption will not prevent future drought losses.
A necessary assumption's negation must logically break the conclusion.
3
Evaluate and eliminate distractors.
Financial cost, resistance to root pathogens under normal rainfall, and farmer interest address implementation, secondary benefits, or adoption logistics rather than necessary logical preconditions of the biological claim.
Non-essential facts, out-of-scope details, and unwarranted extrapolations are not required assumptions.

Key Concept

Identifying Necessary Assumptions using the Negation Test
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Identifying Underlying Assumptions

More questions from this topic