Question

Difficulty: MediumRhetorical Structure and Sentence Function

Read the passage below. Complete {{blank_1}} by inserting the sentence that functions to explicitly concede the technical utility of an innovation while asserting that its primary driver was diplomatic rather than pragmatic.

Answer:During the late sixteenth century, Venetian cartographers increasingly abandoned purely decorative portolan charts in favor of mathematical projection models to map the Adriatic coastline. Standard historiography attributes this transition entirely to pragmatic nautical necessity driven by expanding maritime trade routes. However, recent analyses of archival records reveal that political sovereignty played a far more decisive role: the Venetian Senate explicitly commissioned chorographic surveys to assert territorial jurisdiction over disputed coastal enclaves against Habsburg claims. 【While these nautical projections undoubtedly improved navigational precision, their primary impetus was diplomatic rather than navigational.】 Consequently, the cartographic shift was not merely a technical evolution, but a calculated instrument of statecraft. By embedding administrative boundaries within scientifically authoritative charts, Venice sought to codify its hegemony under the guise of objective empirical representation.

Answer

The sentence 'While these nautical projections undoubtedly improved navigational precision, their primary impetus was diplomatic rather than navigational.' correctly fills the blank because it acknowledges (concedes) the practical navigational benefits of the charts while maintaining that the primary motive was political sovereignty.
The sentence 'While these nautical projections undoubtedly improved navigational precision, their primary impetus was diplomatic rather than navigational.' performs the exact rhetorical function requested: it concedes that nautical improvements occurred ('undoubtedly improved navigational precision') while subordinating that fact to the author's main claim regarding diplomatic motivation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the rhetorical context surrounding the blank.
The preceding sentence notes that the Venetian Senate commissioned maps to assert territorial jurisdiction against Habsburg claims. The subsequent sentence concludes that the cartographic shift was a calculated instrument of statecraft.
Understanding the surrounding logic establishes what structural role the missing sentence must play to maintain coherence.
2
Determine the specific functional requirement specified by the prompt.
The sentence must concede technical utility ('improved navigational precision') while subordinate/redirecting focus to diplomatic impetus ('primary impetus was diplomatic').
This bridges the traditional view (nautical necessity) with the author's argument (statecraft/sovereignty).
3
Verify sentence fit within the passage.
The targeted sentence completes the transition smoothly from Senate commissions to the overarching conclusion introduced by 'Consequently'.
Ensures structural alignment and semantic consistency across the passage.

Key Concept

Rhetorical Structure and Sentence Function
Rate this question