Question

Difficulty: HardMain Idea and Primary Purpose

Passage:

For decades following the landmark 1872–1876 Challenger expedition, physical oceanographers conceptualized deep-ocean circulation as a sluggish, wind-driven drift primarily confined to upper-layer thermal dynamics. This paradigm was disrupted in the mid-twentieth century when oceanographer Henry Stommel proposed a radical theoretical framework for abyssal circulation. Stommel hypothesized that deep-water formation, restricted to narrow subpolar regions in the North Atlantic and Antarctic, creates intense downward convective plumes. To maintain mass conservation across the global ocean, these localized sinking regions must feed deep western boundary currents that transport cold water equatorward. Crucially, Stommel predicted that slow, uniform upward upwelling throughout the ocean interior would balance this deep inflow, driving a counterintuitive poleward flow within the deep ocean interior itself. Initial skepticism from empirical oceanographers persisted until 1957, when Stommel and John Swallow deployed neutral-buoyancy floats to directly measure the predicted deep boundary current off the coast of South Carolina. Beyond merely verifying a physical current, Stommel’s model fundamentally reoriented oceanography from a purely descriptive science of empirical observations into a predictive, dynamics-driven discipline that integrates localized fluid mechanics with global climate systems.

Based on the passage, which of the following statements correctly characterize the main idea or primary purpose of the text? Select all that apply.

  1. To explain how Henry Stommel’s theoretical framework for abyssal circulation challenged established oceanographic paradigms and transformed the discipline into a predictive science.Answer
  2. To articulate the key theoretical mechanisms—such as subpolar convective plumes and balancing interior upwelling—that define Stommel��s model of deep-ocean movement.Answer
  3. C
    To demonstrate that empirical data gathered during the nineteenth-century Challenger expedition was methodologically flawed and misleading.
  4. D
    To assert that subpolar convective sinking is the exclusive driver governing all surface and deep thermal dynamics across global ocean basins.
  5. E
    To provide a detailed technical exposition of the mechanical engineering principles behind neutral-buoyancy float instrumentation.

Answer

The correct statements are the ones describing how Stommel's theoretical framework challenged established paradigms to transform oceanography into a predictive science, and articulating the key theoretical mechanisms (subpolar convective plumes and balancing interior upwelling) defining the model.
The passage focuses on how Henry Stommel developed a revolutionary theoretical model for abyssal circulation—driven by localized subpolar sinking, western boundary currents, and interior upwelling—which transformed oceanography from a descriptive enterprise into a predictive science. Therefore, the choice explaining Stommel's impact on oceanographic paradigms and the choice articulating his specific theoretical mechanisms correctly encapsulate the main idea and primary purpose.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the passage structure and thesis
The text begins by framing the historical background (post-Challenger view of sluggish circulation), introduces Stommel's theoretical innovation (abyssal circulation mechanisms), notes empirical verification (1957 float experiment), and concludes with the major outcome (shifting oceanography to a predictive discipline).
Determining overall primary purpose requires synthesizing the main topic across all paragraphs and structural shifts.
2
Evaluate primary claims against main purpose options
The statement regarding Stommel challenging established paradigms and transforming the discipline accurately reflects the broad primary purpose. The statement summarizing the specific theoretical mechanisms captures the core content presented in the body of the passage.
Main idea questions assess both the overarching communicative goal of the author and the central arguments supporting that goal.
3
Eliminate scope traps, extreme statements, and detail references
Claims regarding flawed Challenger data extrapolate unsupported conclusions. Claims asserting an exclusive driver for all ocean dynamics overstate the author's qualified arguments. The choice focusing on neutral-buoyancy instrumentation elevates a minor supporting detail into a primary purpose.
Distractors in GRE main idea questions frequently distort tone, misidentify supporting details as central claims, or make unwarranted inferences.

Key Concept

Identifying Main Idea and Primary Purpose in Academic Reading Comprehension
Rate this question