Question

Difficulty: MediumCollocation and Idiomatic Fit

Although the lead archivist asserted that the newly unearthed correspondence would radically challenge existing accounts of the diplomatic summit, the documents are in fact entirely ______ prevailing historical consensus. Which of the following options best completes the blank to satisfy standard academic English collocation and idiomatic fit?

  1. consonant withAnswer
  2. B
    at variance to
  3. C
    incompatible with
  4. D
    alien from
  5. E
    beholden of

Answer

The phrase 'consonant with' correctly completes the sentence logically and idiomatically.
The phrase 'consonant with' is the standard academic idiom meaning in agreement or harmony with. Rhetorically, the sentence uses the concession marker 'Although' alongside 'in fact' to set up a contrast between what the archivist asserted (that the letters would challenge consensus) and reality. Thus, the blank must express that the documents agree with existing consensus, and 'consonant with' satisfies both the semantic requirement and standard prepositional collocation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze structural contrast clues in the sentence stem.
The opening concession 'Although...' signals a contrast between the archivist's claim (that the documents would 'radically challenge' consensus) and the empirical reality ('in fact...').
The sentence requires a phrase denoting agreement or harmony with 'prevailing historical consensus'.
2
Evaluate candidate words for semantic fit.
Phrases meaning 'in agreement with' or 'consistent with' fit the logical context.
To complete the contrast with 'radically challenge', the actual documents must align with existing historical accounts.
3
Verify standard prepositional complementation and idiomatic usage.
'Consonant' correctly pairs with the preposition 'with' ('consonant with'). Phrases like 'at variance to', 'alien from', and 'beholden of' use incorrect prepositional complements.
Standard academic English requires precise prepositional collocations.

Key Concept

Collocation and Idiomatic Fit
Estimated Time:1m 15s
Rate this question