Question

Difficulty: MediumIdentifying Conclusions and Main Claims

Recent genomic sequencing of ancient emmer wheat grains recovered across Near Eastern archaeological sites reveals a striking pattern: despite centuries of deliberate cultivation, genetic diversity remained virtually constant until a sudden, severe bottleneck occurred around 7,000 BCE. Archaeological historians traditionally attributed this shift to catastrophic climate aridification that forced farmers to rely on a few resilient cultivars. However, isotopic analysis of contemporary livestock teeth indicates stable precipitation levels and diverse forage during this exact period. Instead, the sudden homogenization coincides precisely with the widespread adoption of centralized, state-managed seed storage facilities. Therefore, early administrative centralization, rather than environmental stress, was the decisive driver behind the reduction in crop genetic variation.

Based on the passage above, which of the following statements express a main conclusion or primary claim advanced by the argument? Select all that apply.

  1. Early state-managed centralized seed storage, rather than climatic hardship, was primarily responsible for the loss of genetic diversity in early cultivated emmer wheat.Answer
  2. B
    Climatic aridification around 7,000 BCE forced Near Eastern agrarian societies to abandon diverse cultivars in favor of drought-resistant crops.
  3. Administrative developments in early agrarian societies had a far greater impact on crop genetic homogenization than did environmental shifts during the period around 7,000 BCE.Answer
  4. D
    Isotopic analysis of livestock teeth provides conclusive proof that prehistoric farmers intentionally selected genetically uniform seeds.
  5. E
    Genomic sequencing of ancient plant remains is less methodologically reliable than isotopic analysis when reconstructing agricultural history.

Answer

The main conclusions of the passage are that administrative centralization was the primary driver of genetic homogenization in early emmer wheat, and that administrative shifts had a larger impact on crop genetic variation than environmental changes did during this period.
The author's primary goal is to replace the traditional climate-based explanation for seed genetic homogenization with an administrative explanation. The final sentence, signaled by 'Therefore', explicitly states that early administrative centralization was the decisive driver behind the reduction in crop genetic variation. Both the statement emphasizing state-managed seed storage over climatic hardship and the statement highlighting administrative developments over environmental shifts accurately rephrase this core thesis.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the background context and traditional viewpoint
The passage notes that genetic diversity dropped sharply around 7,000 BCE and mentions the traditional theory attributing this to climate aridification.
Differentiating background claims from author claims is necessary to locate the main conclusion.
2
Locate the structural pivot and counter-evidence
The signal word 'However' introduces isotopic evidence showing stable precipitation, undermining the traditional climate explanation.
Recognizing structural contrast clues reveals where the author turns against the opposing view.
3
Extract the final conclusion signal and statement
The structural signal 'Therefore' introduces the author's primary claim: administrative centralization, not environmental stress, drove crop genetic homogenization.
Conclusion indicator words signal the core thesis of a Critical Reasoning argument.

Key Concept

Identifying Main Claims and Conclusions
Rate this question