Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardMain Idea and Primary Purpose

For mid-twentieth-century economic historians, Karl Polanyi’s framework established a rigid dichotomy between pre-industrial economies, which were presumed to be governed exclusively by social reciprocity and state-administered redistribution, and modern industrial economies driven by price-making markets. Polanyi specifically asserted that ancient Mesopotamian commerce operated without genuine market mechanisms, relying instead entirely on palace and temple redistributive administration. However, recent epigraphic analyses of Old Assyrian cuneiform tablets from Kültepe (c. 1900 BCE) have significantly challenged this canonical model. These administrative and private records reveal sophisticated merchant networks conducting long-distance trade in tin and textiles, employing private credit instruments, adjusting prices dynamically in response to regional supply and demand, and organizing profit-sharing investment partnerships. Rather than confirming either pure state redistribution or a completely unencumbered market system, the Kültepe archives indicate that price-forming market behaviors operated within heavily institutionalized, non-monetized societal structures. Consequently, contemporary scholars contend that Polanyi’s binary model oversimplifies ancient economic history by failing to recognize how market mechanisms and state oversight coexisted in pre-industrial societies.

Which of the following best states the primary purpose of the passage?

  1. A
    To demonstrate that ancient Mesopotamian merchants developed financial instruments identical to modern market systems
  2. B
    To detail the specific contractual arrangements and investment partnerships used by Old Assyrian merchants at Kültepe
  3. To reexamine a traditional economic dichotomy in light of recent findings regarding ancient commercial practicesAnswer
  4. D
    To refute the contention that state administration played any role in regulating pre-industrial long-distance trade
  5. E
    To explain why Polanyi's theoretical framework remains the dominant model for analyzing ancient Mesopotamian economies

Answer

The primary purpose of the passage is to reexamine a traditional economic dichotomy in light of recent findings regarding ancient commercial practices.
The correct option accurately synthesizes the passage's primary purpose. The text starts by describing Polanyi's classic dichotomy separating pre-industrial redistributive economies from modern market economies, introduces recent epigraphic discoveries from Kültepe that reveal market behaviors in ancient Assyria, and concludes that contemporary historians use these findings to challenge and refine Polanyi's binary model.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the structural organization of the passage
The passage begins by presenting a traditional historical framework (Polanyi's dichotomy between pre-industrial redistributive economies and modern market economies), introduces new empirical evidence (Old Assyrian tablets from Kültepe), and concludes with a scholarly synthesis that qualifies the traditional view.
Identifying the rhetorical trajectory helps isolate the main idea from supporting details.
2
Evaluate the author's main objective
The author's goal is to show how new evidence leads contemporary scholars to question Polanyi's rigid binary model and recognize a more nuanced reality where market mechanisms and state structures coexisted.
The primary purpose must reflect the overall synthesis of the argument, not just the background context or specific empirical evidence.
3
Match the synthesized purpose against the option choices
The option stating that the passage reexamines a traditional economic dichotomy using recent findings directly reflects the central narrative arc.
It avoids scope errors (focusing solely on Kültepe contract types) and distortion errors (claiming total refutation of state roles or complete identity with modern markets).

Key Concept

Identifying Main Idea and Primary Purpose in Academic Reading Comprehension Passages
Rate this question

Topics

Main Idea and Primary Purpose

More questions from this topic