Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyParsing Complex Syntax, Reversals, and Double Negatives

Despite the critic's assertion that the historical study was not without merit, the general consensus among scholars remained that the work was largely unoriginal. Which of the following best describes the critic's actual assessment of the study?

  1. The critic believed that the study possessed at least some worth or value.Answer
  2. B
    The critic believed that the study was completely lacking in educational value.
  3. C
    The critic believed that the study was an exceptional masterpiece in its field.
  4. D
    The critic believed that the study was superior to previous works on the same topic.
  5. E
    The critic agreed completely with the consensus that the study was unoriginal.

Answer

The critic believed that the study possessed at least some worth or value.
The correct answer accurately resolves the double negative construction 'not without merit'. In English syntax, combining 'not' with 'without' creates a qualified positive meaning, signifying that the historical study does indeed possess some degree of merit or value.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify key syntactic and negation markers in the sentence stem.
The phrase contains a double negative: 'not' + 'without merit'.
Resolving double negatives is essential to determining the overall logical polarity of the statement.
2
Cancel out the double negation to find the equivalent positive meaning.
'Not without merit' means 'has some merit' or 'possesses value'.
Two negative terms applied to the same concept cancel each other, yielding a moderately positive claim.
3
Select the option that reflects this qualified positive interpretation.
The statement expressing that the study possessed at least some worth or value correctly conveys the critic's view.
This accurately matches the resolved meaning of the double negative construct.

Key Concept

Parsing Double Negatives and Complex Syntactic Reversals
Rate this question

Topics

Parsing Complex Syntax, Reversals, and Double Negatives

More questions from this topic